Obama-Hagel?

A reader dissents:

Your huffing and puffing about Chuck Hagel being a good pick to be Obama’s VP has inspired me to write as few other topics on your (often controversial) blog have.  There could be, in my view, few more poor choices for Obama.  First of all, your "Team of Rivals" analogy isn’t really borne out by reality; Salmon Chase, William Seward, Edwin Stanton, Edward Bates were all rivals of Lincoln’s within the Republican Party. Lincoln’s "team of rivals" was not composed of members of the opposing political party (unless you make the tortured argument that some of the men in his cabinet had ties to the then-dying American Whig Party). 

You are suggesting that Barack Obama balance out his liberalism by picking a conservative, but as an Obama supporter myself, and one whose support is based on the issues, not intellectual-historical fascination or cult-of-identity politics, I would be livid if Obama picked someone like Hagel as his VP.  Post-partisan is not the same as non-partisan. Obama still has positions on the issues, and those positions are radically different in many ways from the views of Chuck Hagel.  Just because Hagel is handsome, has served in the military, and is criticial of Bush, McCain, and the war, does not make him a good pick.  One glance at Hagel’s positions on the issues will reveal that far from being a proper political replacement for Obama should tragedy befall him in office, a President Hagel’s politics would amount to a reversal of any/all accomplishments that an Obama presidency will have made.

Another adds:

For years now Chuck Hagel has been my favorite Republican in the Senate. He’s the real McCain: he has all of the virtues associated with the presumed GOP nominee but without the extreme narcissistic phoniness, or, in George Will’s term, "moral vanity." And for many reasons I’d welcome Hagel onto the Democratic ticket with Obama, as it would send a clear message about the future, shore up a few of Obama’s political weaknesses, and goose the Democrats’ odds in the electoral college. 

The sticking point, of course, is choice: Hagel has never offered even an inch of wiggle room on the Grail Of All Social Issues, so I can’t imagine the party would accept him as the VP, one heart beat away from the presidency, despite the reservoir of good will he’s accumulated from voters on my side of the political spectrum. The problem really isn’t Roe v.Wade per se; it’s that for a generation choice has loomed over both parties as the defining tribal credential, the way of signaling that "you’re really one of us." Which is why McCain was ultimately acceptable to the bulk of the Republican base and Giuliani was not.

Hagel could give a speech saying he’d support President Obama’s picks for the Supreme Court a la Justices Ginsburg and Souter but I doubt that would be enough. There are plenty of pro-choice Republicans and plenty of pro-life Democrats (like, say, Bob Casey). But this issue festers at the heart of our partisan culture; and I can’t believe Obama could embrace a running mate, even such a worthy one, whose policy positions are so far from his own.

Where The Babes Are

Derbyshire on the only signs of life in American politics:

P. J. O’Rourke says that if you want to latch on to a consequential, going-places political movement fired by real passion, follow the babes. Where there are pretty young women cheering and clapping in droves, there is politics with a future. By this standard, this campaign has offered us two inspirational political futures: Barack Obama’s, and Ron Paul’s.

Maliki’s Momentum

We shouldn’t get too optimistic:

There is a real danger that Maliki will fall prey to his new found (over)confidence and push the Sadrist movement into a corner. A two-pronged plan might be in the works. Part one would be to arrest large numbers of Sadrists in Sadr City instead of doing discriminate raids against extremist cells. Part two would be a renewed effort to preclude Sadrists from the provincial elections unless JAM is completely disbanded, or take other measures to decisively tilt the electoral playing field against the Sadr Trend. If Sadr and his movement are near defeat, these steps might be the nail in their coffin. But they don’t seem near defeat–they seem wounded. And wounded, cornered animals lash out.

Sistani vs McCain

The entire premise of John McCain’s view of Iraq policy going forward is that the US will be able to position permanent military bases in the heart of the Middle East, on the model of Japan and South Korea. The trouble is: Iraq is part of the holiest territory in Islam and a pact with infidel occupiers simply isn’t going to wash:

Iraq’s most revered Shia cleric Grand Ayatollah Ali al-Sistani has strongly objected to a ‘security accord’ between the US and Iraq. The Grand Ayatollah has reiterated that he would not allow Iraq to sign such a deal with "the US occupiers" as long as he was alive, a source close to Ayatollah Sistani said. The source added the Grand Ayatollah had voiced his strong objection to the deal during a meeting with Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki in the holy city of Najaf on Thursday. The remarks were made amid reports that the Iraqi government might sign a long-term framework agreement with the United States, under which Washington would be allowed to set up permanent military bases in the country and US citizens would be granted immunity from legal prosecution in the country.

Sistani is right, of course. A permanent pesudo-occupation would be dreadful for the US (we need less empire, not more) and for Iraq (no Islamic democracy is going to establish itself under the auspices of the United States military).

In Praise Of Guilt

Ron Rosenbaum defends liberal guilt:

It’s especially surprising to hear "guilt" being disparaged by conservatives, since they present themselves as moralists; they are quick to decry liberals for seeking to abolish guilt over various practices conservatives deem immoral. But was slavery not immoral? For those conservatives who make a fetish of "values": Was not the century of institutionalized racism and segregation that followed the end of slavery a perpetuation of "flawed values" that the nation should feel an enduring guilt over? For those conservatives who are forever speaking of the way they value history and memory more than liberals: Should we abolish the history and memory of slavery and racism just because they’re no longer legally institutionalized?

Yglesias Award Nominee

"If Republicans  and conservatives want to finance the government in a less destructive way (as we should!), we are going to have to find substitutes for these harmful, looming, pre-scheduled tax increases. 

We cannot wish away this problem. And I wish Peter Ferrara would use his considerable fiscal ingenuity to try to solve it, rather than closing his eyes and denying it," – David Frum, attempting to bring a little conservative reality into Republican fiscal debates.

The Wilfully Ignorant

They may be the swing vote in this election, alas. From a focus group of non-voters:

For instance, here’s Dorita, opining about Obama: "I’m a little concerned. I don’t know enough about his Muslim background and their beliefs and how he views everything. I’m a little concerned. I need to check his background."

You do that, Dorita.

Here’s Josh on Obama: "He’s representing a minority in more than one case. He is African American and he is Muslim. And in light of that…it does feel like we’re being judged or pounded down on because we want to carry a gun or we want to wear the American flag pin."

Here’s Melinda, clearly the GOP’s dream voter: "I just really feel like he’s…not a people pleaser as in the Americans, but the other people who don’t necessarily need to be pleased, the other, the enemies if you will, I don’t know. I’m just not real positive on that."