Alyssa Rosenberg calls TLC's All-American Muslim, which premieres on Sunday, "one of the best new shows of the fall":
One of the most important things that distinguishes All-American Muslim from its reality-show peers is simply that the cast is uniformly likable and engaging. … The show never treats the difficult and ongoing project of trying to reconcile the demands of faith and the possibilities of the modern world as if it's easy, or if there's an obvious answer the characters are missing. And it manages to generate powerful tension out of that most anodyne subject: tolerance.
On the other hand, Jorge Rivas is wary.
The Dish 