PM Carpenter is on a very similar page as I am, but with a different conclusion:
Who, in my opinion, is right? Both Greenwald and Keller, for both men make claims based on assumptions of honorable, professional behavior and genuine intent. Perhaps this is that element of this democratic socialist’s ineradicable conservatism peeping out–that is, my belief that some traditions are worthy traditions merely by virtue of their proven serviceability and violent collapse of other approaches–but I’d give the edge to Keller, for one simple, and for me primal, reason: Greenwald’s moralism scares the hell out of me.
The Dish 