by Patrick Appel
In response to this post, a reader writes:
I am one of 6 children and a member of an even larger Irish-Slovak Catholic extended family. My wife and I are both college graduates with liberal arts degrees; getting by just fine, but by no means with the disposal income that would be required to throw a nice event for the number of people whom we consider ourselves to be really close to. Once invites are extended beyond parents and siblings, the number of people we would “need” to invite would immediately jump into the hundreds. We simply did not have the budget for this (and it was not a matter of choosing not to dip into savings; savings do not exist). So, with some emotional and brief interpersonal turmoil, we only invited our immediate families and a close personal friend each to stay at 2 beach houses we rented for a weekend in Cannon Beach, Oregon. Our guest list was 30 people. We prepared the food ourselves, we bought the beer, wine, and liquor from costco, there was no photographer, or other hired help. It was a family celebration, as it seems, is the whole idea behind a wedding ceremony, in the first place.
We were able to provide a level of setting/accommodation, food, beverage and activity that we could never have dreamed of if we had to extend invitations beyond the sphere that we did. But, we were able to host an amazing event for the 30 most important people in our lives, that they all still talk about. It was an amazing weekend for all involved. In fact, though we would have liked to share that experience with many, many more people, I think that everyone– us included –enjoyed that experience much more than a rented party facility with standard catered fare, DJ/band, floral centerpieces, etc. We recognized the importance and significance of making our commitment to each other in front of those who are most important in our lives, and wanted to provide them with an experience that they would always remember. I think we definitely achieved our goal, and though the cost was definitely in the thousands of dollars, it was much less than half of what the “average” wedding costs today.
Both my wife and I have many friends from the East/West/Midwest young educated class that have chosen to celebrate their nuptials in similar fashion. I think a nice intimate event shared with those you love most is a much more pleasant and ultimately meaningful celebration than the very expensive cookie cutter fiesta that leaves all involved feeling frazzled and stressed. If I am going to spend $30k on something, I am going to get a lot more out of it than what I have witnessed siblings, cousins, and friends get out of their rather humdrum, but very expensive weddings.
Another reader:
Maybe I was lucky, but last year when my husband and I decided to abandon our plans for a blow out wedding, and instead opt for a small ceremony at my parents’ house over Christmas with family already in town, no one was quick to judge our financial situation. When we sent out invites, I told everyone “I found out I was going to have to pay $600 for table cloths. That’s not happening.” I don’t care how much money we have — that’s just ludicrous! Instead of the financial judgement, though, we got frequent calls asking “Are you pregnant???” from any family or friends over the age of 50. When we mentioned this to friends closer to our age, it was amazing — each of them said “That hadn’t even crossed my mind!” Either there’s a big generational divide in assumptions here or our friends were lying to our faces.
Anyway, our wedding was amazing and meaningful and perfect, and exceedingly cheap to boot! We even streamed it online for the family and friends we had to cut off the invite list to keep costs down. They were happy to watch, and happier to not have to attend or bring a gift. It was perfect all around! (And I’m still not pregnant, Uncle Jim.)
A final reader makes an important point:
“Average cost” does not necessarily mean “typical cost.” This is especially true with something like a wedding, where the wealthy spend exorbitant sums and skew the statistic. If four couples have $9,000 weddings and one couple has a $100,000 wedding, the average wedding cost is $27,000 — but let’s not interpret that to mean that that’s what most people should expect to pay.
A 2007 WSJ article provided better numbers:
For the three surveys, the median wedding cost is closer to $15,000. The median is the middle figure when you line up a set of numbers in order of size. It is a popular choice for social statistics because it is unperturbed by very small or very large numbers.