We are considering nixing the Daily Wrap as a feature but would like to get reader feedback first. Is it useful to you? It’s very time-consuming for us. But if enough readers find it helpful, it’s your blog as well as ours. So let us know in the above poll if you feel strongly either way, or if you barely notice it at all.
Author: Andrew Sullivan
Hathos Alert
From the American Enterprise Institute’s countdown of the “21 Greatest Conservative Rap Songs Of All Time” is a close-reading of Dr. Dre’s “Still D.R.E.” featuring Snoop Dogg. It is not apparently a parody:
[J]ust because something is hip and new it is not necessarily better (“Still the beats bang, still doing my thang / Since I left, ain’’ too much changed, still”). Hope and change are not a substitute for skill and competence: “I bring the fire till you’re soaking in your seat / It’s not a fluke, it’s been tried, I’m the truth.” But of course, even Dr. Young’s tried and tested approach to producing beats is of limited worth without hard work. From the moment he wakes up till the moment he goes to sleep, his mind is focused on his professional obligations (“Treat my rap like Cali weed, I smoke til I sleep / Wake up in the A.M., compose a beat”). But that does not mean that he is unwilling to dedicate some of his time to teaching, passing on the truth of the ages to new generations (“Kept my ear to the streets, signed Eminem / He’s triple platinum, doing 50 a week”).
Near the end of the song, all this culminates in a warning to wannabe revolutionaries everywhere: “Dr. Dre be the name / Still running the game.” And this extends, of course, to those who believe that a Marxist utopia can be established through democratically endorsed redistribution of wealth. As Dr. Young explains in “Forgot About Dre,” a song from his next album: “If it was up to me / You motherf****** would stop coming up to me / With your hands out lookin’ up to me / Like you want something free.”
Racism In The World, Ctd
A reader writes:
I found your post intriguing, but then I saw this takedown of errors in the dataset. I think a correction is definitely due, since at least some of the results appear to be opposite to the truth.
Yep: one stats expert has spotted a “fat finger” in the Bangladesh data:
“Yes” and “No” got swapped in the second round of the survey, which means that 28.3% of Bangladeshis said they wouldn’t want neighbors of a different race – not 71.7%.
That’s a huge difference. But it may be restricted to Bangladesh. Another reader:
I don’t see how that map gives us a grasp of racism around the world. With the exception of France and a couple of other First World countries, this seems to be a much better indicator of each country’s knowledge of First World norms.
A study like this has to be tailored to each country’s level of sophistication. The average person in America or Canada lives in a metropolitan area with easy access to mass media. Regardless of whether or not they are racist, the average American KNOWS that you can’t say “I don’t want to live with people of another race.” However, the average person in India or Bangladesh lives in a rural area and has almost no interaction with people of other races and very little exposure to mass media. When you ask them them a question about neighbors, all they’re really thinking is “I don’t know want my village taken over by foreigners.” Racist? Possibly. Unsophisticated thinking? Definitely.
I am an American of Indian descent and briefly lived in India. I have no trouble believing India is the most racist country out there, but my experience in India also gives me some insight into how the survey questions are perceived by the average person there. You simply can’t ask the same question in the U.S. and India and think that you are measuring the same thing.
Another:
Regarding India, I would not discount Islam or religion in general as a big part of the explanation. For starters, India has (depending on the source) between 160 and 180 million Muslims, more than any country other than Indonesia and Pakistan. And most of the rest of the population are Hindu and Hinduism is very much tied into being Indian and therefore of a certain physical appearance if not race. When I spent a semester in India 21 years ago, I certainly at times felt like I was being treated differently (for good and ill) because I was white. Mixed up in the religion issue is the fact that skin color is a big deal in Indian society. Light skin is an ideal physical trait, especially in northern India. Most of the movie stars have light skin (and would not stick out in Rome) and there are skin lighteners for sale in every drug store or grocery. Additionally, you have the legacy of British rule. Indians have certainly not forgotten that they were relatively recently under the thumb of white folks.
Another:
You don’t mention it, but France’s racism status has a lot to do with Islam too. Hatred from and for Arab and African muslims is incredible there. As an American married to a French woman, the amount of open and overt racism coming from both sides is incredible to see. (Jews don’t feel too good there either, but that’s another conversation.)
Iran’s Election Just Got Interesting, Ctd
First, former President Rafsanjani made a surprise entrance into the race. Now, the Guardian Council has delayed its announcement of the approved candidates for the election, which will give those candidates just over three weeks to campaign. David Patrikarakos notes how the regime is already attempting to discredit Rafsanjani:
Rafsanjani would have support from both conservatives and reformists, and, critically, he could win. So the question remains: will he pass the vetting process?
Ayatollah Ahmad Jannati heads the Guardian Council and is a close ally of Khamenei. He would probably like to reject Rafsanjani’s candidacy outright, but things are not that simple. … Rafsanjani is too powerful to be swatted aside like so many other candidates but, equally, the regime is determined to avoid a repeat of the popular unrest of 2009. … It is a sign of how isolated Iran’s ruling elite have become that Rafsanjani, a commercially minded pragmatist who never displayed any great love of reform beyond what was practically necessary, is now seen as a grave internal threat to the regime. Even were he elected there is no knowing how reformist he would be: his track record shouldn’t give any hope to the regime’s opponents, and how far he has changed remains to be seen.
Meanwhile, Laura Rozen takes a look at Saeed Jalili, the country’s top nuclear negotiator, who may emerge as the hardline establishment’s choice now that Rafsanjani is running:
Jalili, 47, a trusted Khamenei aide who has served since 2007 as the secretary of Iran’s Supreme National Security Council (SNSC) — the Iranian equivalent of National Security Advisor–has managed to largely bypass the bitter feuds that have polarized Iran’s ruling factions, analysts and associates observe. As a candidate who may be able to unite key conservative factions, a Jalili presidency potentially offers the prospect of a more consolidated Iranian leadership, which might be able to muster internal Iranian consensus if the Leader decides to make a deal, some analysts suggest. …
“I think he is the anointed one,” Suzanne Maloney, a former State Department Iran analyst at the Brookings Institution Saban Center, told Al-Monitor. The regime “may test run it, see how he [does], if anybody else appears to take off.” … Current and former Iranian associates describe Jalili as a pious and intelligent man, who has earned the trust of the Supreme Leader, but shown a disinclination to deeply engage with the modern world.
(Photo: Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad (R) and Esfandyar Rahim Mashaie (L) flash the sign of victory during their press conference after Mashaie registered his candidacy for the upcoming presidential election at the interior ministry in Tehran on May 11, 2013. Iran is expected to wrap up the five-day registration of candidates on May 13, leaving the fate of the hopefuls in the hands of the Guardians Council, an unelected body controlled by religious conservatives appointed by Khamenei. By Behrouz Mehri/AFP/Getty Images)
Is Race Only A Social Construct? Ctd
In a long and wonky post on genetics and race, Razib Khan defends a biological understanding of “race”:
The history of a population affects [its] genome, and its genome affects the nature of its traits and diseases. Because of differences across populations statistical geneticists with medical aims routinely restrict their data set to individuals of one population. And, within groups like African Americans which are admixed there is variation in disease risk by genomic fraction. Though an individual with 60 percent African ancestry may feel and say they are no more or no less African American than someone who is 80 percent African in ancestry, there are differences in disease susceptibilities.
There is no Platonic sense where there are perfect categories with ideal uses. Rather, we muddle on, making usage of heuristics and frameworks which are serviceable for the moment. We lose our way when we ignore the multi-textured nature of the issues.
But one of his commenters, like TNC’s, suggests using a term other than “race” to describe genetically similar populations:
The classical definition and conception of the word ‘race’ is too entrenched and changing it hardly seems a battle worth fighting (and likely futile anyway). Best to adopt a different term entirely.
Face Of The Day
No, not Michele Bachmann. A woman in vampire make-up attends the traditional park picnic on the first day of the annual Wave-Gotik Treffen, or Wave and Goth Festival, on May 17, 2013 in Leipzig, Germany. The four-day festival, in which elaborate fashion is a must, brings together over 20,000 Wave, Goth and steam punk enthusiasts from all over the world for concerts, readings, films, a Middle Ages market and workshops. By Marco Prosch/Getty Images.
Why The IRS Scandal Matters
Ramesh Ponnuru sees it as a general problem for the administration:
Ten days ago the president gave a commencement speech at Ohio State University urging graduates not to view government as “some separate, sinister entity.” Liberals prefer that people view government, as former Representative Barney Frank once put it, as just the name we use for the things we do together. The IRS scandal makes the government look more like, well, a separate, sinister entity — and that can’t help the party of government activism.
Wilkinson focuses on a specific example:
The scandal over the Internal Revenue Service targeting conservative non-profit organisations for extra scrutiny comes at an inauspicious time for the Obama administration. When Obamacare goes in to full effect in January, the IRS will be vested with an array of new powers. Americans will be required to prove to the agency that they have a “qualifying” health plan, or pay a penalty. The IRS is also charged with passing confidential tax info to the Department of Health and Human Services, which will determine eligibility for new health-care subsidies. Americans will be required to report changes to their lives that might affect their eligibility for subsidies. A new job, a raise, a move to a new state, a change in marital status, a change in hours worked can all trigger a requirement to update the IRS.
Which means the stable-clearing must be fair but decisive. Anyone connected to what appears to be a lefty cabal of mid-level officials should be thrown out on their ear.
The View From Your Window
The Hillary Clinton Of Soccer
A tour through David Beckham’s constantly changing haircuts.
Shitty Economic Policy
Venezuelans find out the hard way why price controls are a bad idea – the entire country is running short of toilet paper.


