In Search of Activist Architects

Noting that Thomas Jefferson “believed that architecture embodied the soul of his new country,” Doug Wignall urges today’s architects to be more assertive in their social roles:

[T]he profession of architect has lost its way in mainstream consciousness. We have become less relevant, we have become more commoditized—largely because we are not inserting ourselves into public dialogue as leaders of the discussion and instruments of change. Young people want to enter a profession where they feel they can make a difference, and while architecture certainly is a vehicle to do that, we have fallen off in our determination to execute it properly…

I wonder about the concept of architect as political hero. I believe that if we don’t go forward with that idea in mind, then we will never fulfill our true potential, that our profession will languish in obscurity. As architects, we are the builders of dreams. I propose that we can and should build dreams beyond the tangible world of the built environment. We have much to contribute to the shaping of public policy that can improve the world. And I argue that there has never been a better time for us to begin.

Battling Over Burials

Yvonne Abraham is “sickened” by Cambridge’s refusal to allow Tamerlan Tsarnaev to be interred in the city:

If we begin to judge who is worthy of burial, and who is not – which, make no mistake, is the precedent being set here – where does it end? Plenty of others have been controlled by irrational thoughts the way the Tsarnaevs were. Many are broken, as Adam Lanza and Seung-Hui Cho demonstrate all too well. As much as we’d like to fully dissociate ourselves from that evil, we can’t. They’re human, like us. We have buried men like this. We have also buried Mafia bosses, some of them mass murderers, sometimes with grand funerals. Do their bodies better deserve to be treated as human, their relatives’ wishes better deserve honoring, because they were motivated by greed and sadism, rather than a twisted, hateful sense of injustice?

Me too. In fact, as a Catholic, I find it disgusting. Even mass murdering Jihadists are human beings. When dead, judgment is between them and their God. It is a core aspect of a humane society to respect the humanity even of the most evil and reprehensible. And this bizarre aversion to burying Tsarnaev in Massachusetts also places the terrorist in a special category of dehumanization. We must resist this if we are to remain a civilized country.We can fight an enemy without dehumanizing them. As soon as you do that, you end up in Donald Rumsfeld’s Abu Ghraib.

Tim Murphy, noting that Tsarnaev’s case is “complicated by the fact that the remains of a Muslim cannot be cremated,” finds other examples of bodies that were kept from burial:

One of the most high-profile cases of domestic terrorism prompted an anti-burial backlash.

After Oklahoma City bomber Timothy McVeigh was sentenced to death in 1997, Congress moved quickly to pass legislation preventing anyone who had been convicted of a federal capital crime from being interred in a veterans’ cemetery. McVeigh’s ashes were scattered.

No cemetery in the city of Chicago would allow the four men hanged for their role in the 1886 Haymarket Riot, in which seven police officers and four civilians were killed in a bombing, to be buried within the city limits. Instead, they were relegated to a plot in the suburb of Forest Park. Leon Czolgosz, the anarchist who assassinated President William McKinley, was dissolved in sulfuric acid, Breaking Bad-style, to prevent admirers from visiting his grave. Lee Harvey Oswald’s corpse was flipped from Dallas cemeteries like a hot potato before finally finding a resting place in Fort Worth.

Perhaps the most heated and prolonged burial battle involved the bodies of American cult members who died at Jonestown, Guyana, in 1978. As historian David Chidester explained in Salvation and Suicide, “Public officials had vehemently resisted any mass burial of the Jonestown dead for fear that such a burial site would become a cultic shrine.” Instead, the bodies languished at Dover Air Force Base in Delaware before arrangements were finally made for a group burial in Oakland, California.

Officials have since announced they have found an undisclosed burial place for Tsarnaev.

Sanford, The GOP, And The Sanctity Of Marriage

Mark Sanford And Elizabeth Colbert Busch Attend Pork & Politics Event

Douthat isn’t surprised by the outcome in South Carolina:

One could imagine a world where the advance of gay marriage, and the apparent failure of traditionalist arguments on the issue, inspired social conservatives to seek both a more comprehensive pro-marriage agenda and less compromised standard bearers for that cause. But for now that doesn’t seem to be happening: Instead we live in a world where the same South Carolina voters who handed their primary to the thrice-married Newt Gingrich just held their noses and voted for Sanford, who famously ditched not only his wife but also his gubernatorial duties while pursuing an adulterous affair. …

For now, at least, I don’t look at left and right and see the beginnings of a neo-Victorian moment. I see a liberalism that feels triumphant about gay marriage and complacent about the institution’s overall decline, and a conservatism that, lacking an obvious way forward, seems half-inclined to just give up the fight.

I don’t disagree with Ross on much of this – but have to add that surely this means – must mean – that the current GOP’s hostility to marriage equality is not really about the state of marriage, but about their fundamentalist inability to see gay people in relationships as equals. How can you write a column about the lack of passion behind social conservatism without noting the real passion that drives the GOP to adopt a position that would deny gay couples any structured legal rights at all?

Dreher looks to the life of John Profumo, a British cabinet minister whose career was ended by a sex scandal, as an alternative to the Sanford comeback. It would certainly make sense of today’s GOP base voters were genuinely concerned about marriage and the family, rather than convulsed with fear and loathing of gays.

(Photo: Former South Carolina Governor and U.S. House of Representatives Republican candidate Mark Sanford talks with supporters during the Charleston Area Chamber of Commerce’s Pork and Politics on April 30, 2013 in Charleston, South Carolina. Republican Mark Sanford is challenging Democrat Elizabeth Colbert Busch in a special election for the House seat vacated by current U.S. Sen. Tim Scott. By Richard Ellis/Getty Images)

Is House Of Cards Too Cynical?

Kevin Spacey and Steny Hoyer recently discussed the question:

“One of the phrases that I hate the most is when people say ‘well, that’s politics,’” Hoyer said, “and your show is a lot about, ‘well, that’s politics.’” People already have an unfairly negative view of politics, Hoyer explained, and “House of Cards” plays into a nihilistic and venal portrait of politics that goes farther than reality.

Spacey acknowledged the point, but chalked it up to the medium, noting that Hollywood makes plenty of movies about the film business than are grimmer than Hollywood really is. That’s drama. And despite Underwood’s tremendous faults, Spacey said he’s found that people appreciate the conniving fictional politician, “because he gets shit done.” The Washington in “House of Cards” may be more morally bankrupt and soulless in the way it does things than the one that exists in reality, but at least it does things — that’s appealing when nothing’s happening in real Washington, he noted. Those are the kinds of roles that appeal to Spacey, he said, noting that he loved “Lincoln” because it grappled with “Lincoln the politician,” as opposed to the saintly figure we usually think.

Yes, Of Course It Was Jihad, Ctd

Simon Shuster has the latest scoop on the bombers’ ties to radical Islam:

Last year, when Tamerlan Tsarnaev spent six months in the Russian region of Dagestan, he had a guide with an unusually deep knowledge of the local Islamist community: a distant cousin named Magomed Kartashov. Six years older than Tsarnaev, Kartashov is a former police officer and freestyle wrestler—and one of the region’s most prominent Islamists.

In 2011 Kartashov founded and became the leader of an organization called the Union of the Just, whose members campaign for sharia law and pan-Islamic unity in Dagestan, often speaking out against U.S. policies across the Muslim world. The group publicly renounces violence. But some of its members have close links to militants; others have served time in prison for weapons possession and abetting terrorism—charges they say were based on fabricated evidence. For Tsarnaev, these men formed a community of pious young Muslims with whom he could discuss his ideas of jihad. Tsarnaev’s mother, Zubeidat, confirmed that her son is Kartashov’s third cousin. The two met for the first time in Dagestan, she said, and “became very close.”

Clinton’s 3am Call

Well, technically 2 am:

[Gregory Hicks] testified that, from on the ground in Libya where he had been among the last people to speak to Ambassador Stevens before he was killed, he spoke with Secretary of State Hillary Clinton directly by phone at 2 a.m. Benghazi time. He briefed her on the terrorist attack — it was never regarded as anything but a terrorist attack — and on the then-ongoing search for Ambassador Stevens, who was feared to be at a hospital controlled by terrorists (to whom Hicks referred, in his testimony, as “the enemy”).

It’s pretty clear to me that by now this is all about wounding Clinton for 2016, when she would be a formidable opponent for the GOP, which lacks anyone close to her stature or popularity, except for Christie, who is now being purged. But it seems to me the kind of wound designed to rile up Hillary-haters in the base rather than moderates in the middle. And make no mistake: Fox’s new-found love for Hillary was all about stopping Obama. Ailes will turn on a dime and demonize her as effectively as the campaign against her in the 1990s. Mike Crowley sizes up the stakes for Clinton:

Whether or not Republicans intended it, the shadow of national politics loomed over Wednesday’s hearing. Hillary Clinton completed a generally well-reviewed tenure of Secretary of State, as evidenced by her sky-high public approval ratings. But Benghazi is a clear black mark on her Foggy Bottom record, one that could haunt Clinton if she runs for president in 2016. Conservatives seized on Hicks’s testimony that, in a call with Clinton on the fateful night, he told her that a terrorist attack was underway–a fact that was slow to appear in the administration’s public rhetoric. Still, despite repeated discussion about what Clinton knew and when she knew it, no smoking gun emerged from Wednesday’s hearing, leading one Congressional Democrat to dismiss questions about her role as a “witch hunt.”

But a member of Hillaryland has suddenly entered the spotlight:

[Hicks] charged that Clinton’s key State Department lieutenant and longtime family retainer, Cheryl Mills, made a concerted effort to block him from meeting with a Congressional delegation and that he had never been interviewed by the FBI in connection to the attack. Hicks said that he had been demoted after asking too many questions of his superiors about their response to Benghazi.

Republicans repeatedly raised the fact that Mills, a former deputy White House counsel and Clinton’s chief of staff at the State Department, personally called Hicks to express that she was upset that he had met with Rep. Jason Chaffetz without a lawyer present. So was the fact that administration lawyers had told Hicks and the Regional Security Officer not to speak with congressional investigators, as well as Hicks’ claim that he briefed Clinton the night of the attack and characterized it as an act of terror. Rep. Jim Jordan of Ohio referred to Mills’ as Clinton’s “fixer” and “as close as you can get to Secretary Clinton.”

The above video shows an interview with Pat Smith, the mother of one of the four consulate victims. The father of the slain Navy SEAL Tyrone Woods is also making the rounds:

When I was approached by Hillary Clinton at the coming home ceremony of the bodies at Andrews Air Force base and she said we are going to go out and we are going to prosecute that person who made the video, I knew that she wasn’t telling the truth, and I think the whole world knows that now.

The Power Of Good Journalism

Steve Brill’s piece on healthcare costs in America is getting results:

Acting on the suggestion of her top data crunchers at the department’s Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS), Sebelius will release a data file that shows the list — or “chargemaster” — prices by all hospitals across the U.S. for the 100 most common inpatient treatment services in 2011. It then compares those prices with what Medicare actually paid hospitals for the same treatments — which was typically a fraction of the chargemaster prices. CMS public-affairs director Brian Cook told me that Sebelius’ action today comes in part in response to TIME’s special report on health-care-pricing practices in the March 4 issue, “Bitter Pill.”

Brill’s advice on the next steps the administration should take:

The feds need to publish chargemaster and Medicare pricing for the most frequent outpatient procedures and diagnostic tests at clinics — two huge profit venues in the medical world. This will be harder — the government doesn’t collect that data as comprehensively — but those outpatient centers and clinics provide a huge portion of American medical care.

But an even bigger step in transparency would be collecting data that Medicare doesn’t have: exactly what insurance companies pay to the various hospitals, testing clinics and other providers for various treatments and services. After all, as the hospitals themselves concede in downplaying their chargemasters, these insurance prices are the ones that affect most patients. But it’s also where there is close to zero transparency.

Previous Dish on Brill’s piece here, here and here. His recent Ask Anything series here.

Dissents Of The Day

A reader writes:

I am a leader in the Jewish community who regularly influences the thinking of American Jews. I consider myself a loving critic of the state of Israel in the sense that I have been there enough to understand its imperfections and am committed enough to have credibility amongst people Israel takes seriously. I see it as my responsibility to regularly speak out when I think Israeli government policy undermines its long term strategic interests and moral standing. I think settlement expansion is a fool’s errand.

And Stephen Hawking’s boycott is making my job immeasurably harder. The people I most need to listen to my loving criticism become hardened by what they see as a global double standard when it comes to Israel and a convenient self righteousness expressed towards the only democracy in the Middle East that would even register such protests.

Yes, the Netanyahu policies have been corrosive to the vision of a Jewish and democratic state. And yes, the historically earned instinct among Jews not to trust the world is emboldened by overtures like Hawking’s. Please Andrew, stop supporting the grandstanding and start partnering with the people most likely to move the needle. Boycotts, divestment and sanctions make it too easy for Israel supporters to point the finger at Palestinian acts of terror and not the internal changes that the Israeli government must make.

I take my reader’s points, but I see no way to end and reverse the settlements if we stay on our current track. Imploring Israel to reverse the de facto annxation under Netanyahu is like spitting into a hurricane. If I saw any sign that the American Jewish establishment or the US Congress or the Christianist right were prepared to put a scintilla of pressure on Israel to reverse the settlements, I’d “start partnering with the people most likely to move the needle.” But the people most capable of moving the needle refuse to, and have been actively complicit in Israel’s democratic death-wish, and actively McCarthyite in their smearing of those who resist. At some point, you either look away or look for alternative strategies.

Another upset reader points to this item:

“Hawking’s decision to join the boycott of Israel is quite hypocritical for an individual who prides himself on his whole intellectual accomplishment. His whole computer-based communications system [he needs because of his motor-neuron disease] runs on a chip designed by Israel’s Intel team. I suggest if he truly wants to pull out of Israel he should also pull out his Intel Core i7 from his tablet,” said Nitsana Darshan-Leitner of Shurat HaDin.

A chip is a chip, for goodness’ sake. There’s no hypocrisy there, unless your mindset is irretrievably tribal. Another dissent:

I generally agree with your criticisms of the Netanyahu government, and your justified disdain for the hardening of Israel towards the Palestinians and the expansion of settlements in the West Bank. But “David has become Goliath”?

Not when Israel is surrounded by extremely well-funded, well-armed and well-populated Arab and Muslim states that still deny its existence, actively talk about wiping it off of the face of the earth, either have or are developing nuclear capability, who encourage the use of violence as the exclusive means to Screen shot 2013-05-09 at 11.22.09 AMsolve the current problems, and who also indulge in some of the most offensive racial stereotyping derogatory to Jews in the primary school education of their children. Israel’s enemies were equally opposed to pre-1967 Israel and post-1967 Israel, to Golda Meir and Moshe Dayan, to Menachim Begin and Yitzhak Rabin, and now to Netanyahu. But we tend to forget or overlook the Arab world’s hatred of pre-1967 Israel because Netanyahu has made it so easy to be critical of post-1967 Israel’s conduct as a state.

I think it would be more appropriate to say that David (i.e., Israel) is a more complex and ambiguous figure than the Bible would have us believe, at times acting in ways we don’t like because of its conviction that it knows more than we do about what it needs to do to survive given the reality on the ground, the reality that it confronts on a daily basis, and the reality that you and I can discuss in the abstract from our safe perch across the Atlantic. And make no mistake about it, while this guy David is a remarkable and worthwhile character, he is at times selfish, inconsiderate, arrogant, narcissistic, impulsive and more than a little dickish, and you just want to hit him upside the head and tell him to straighten out before it’s too late. But he doesn’t chop off peoples arms for stealing, he doesn’t seek the complete and permanent destruction of his neighbors, he lives in fear of Boston Marathon-style terrorist attacks in public places on a daily basis, and he is a democracy, where there is almost even division between those who support the right wing government’s hard line on settlements and border settlements, and those who oppose with the same passion and intensity as you do.

There is no David, and there is no Goliath. That is media oversimplification at its laziest.

(Chart of relative military power in the Middle East compiled by Global Firepower)

The Benghazi Hearing: Reax

Michael Hirsh has a must-read on yesterday’s hearing. At the center of it was Gregory Hicks, the deputy to Ambassador Stevens located in Tripoli at the time of the attack:

The most moving — if still-not-quite scandalous — testimony came from Hicks, who described how he virtually begged for help as Stevens and his colleagues were being killed that night of Sept. 11, 2012. The help never came. The administration’s response has been that Hicks, a diplomat, is no expert in military capabilities, and his allegations have already been directly rebutted by both Gen. Martin Dempsey, the Joint Chiefs chairman, and former Defense Sec. Leon Panetta. Dempsey testified in February that it would have taken “up to 20 hours or so” to get F-16s to the site, and he called them “the wrong tool for the job.”

And what about ground forces?

Hicks had already told Republican investigators about the seven-person rescue team, including four U.S. Special Forces, that was delayed in heading from Tripoli (where Hicks was) to the consulate, after it was under attack. “How did the personnel react,” asked Chaffetz, “at being told to stand down?” Hicks remembered them being furious. “I will quote Lt. Col. Gibson,” said Hicks, referring to the commander at the Special Operations Command Africa who’d expected to join the mission. “He said, ‘This is the first time in my career that a diplomat has more balls than someone in the military.’ ” …

On May 1, 2013, the Pentagon sent a timeline of its actions to the House Armed Services Committee. And according to that, Panetta had OK’d the movement of FAST platoons and a special operations force before 3 a.m. local time, but no aid arrived before the mortar attack that killed Woods and Doherty. According to Hicks, the team wanted to get to Benghazi as quickly as possible. According to Panetta, if it had, it wouldn’t have helped.

The hearing’s key moment for Ed Krayewski:

[Hicks] testified that the ambassador made no mention of a demonstration at the mission in Benghazi, only an attack, and that “[t]he YouTube video was a non-event in Libya,” despite the Obama Administration’s attempts to pin the violence in Libya to protests over a trailer for an anti-Muslim film that had been on YouTube for months. It was all about the video Obama apologists cried in the aftermath of the Benghazi attack (and the run-up to November’s presidential election). That position does not appear to be connected to reality at all.

Kevin Drum sighs:

Rice’s interviews were litigated to death long ago. If you actually review the evidence, it turns out that her language was careful; it was based on CIA talking points; there was (and still is) evidence that the “Innocence of Muslims” video played a role in the attacks; and al-Magariaf was almost certainly wrong about whether the attacks were a long-planned operation. Details here.

But Stephen Hayes points out that “the Weekly Standard reported this week that early versions of those C.I.A. talking points prominently noted that extremists with ties to Al Qaeda were involved in the attacks and that Ansar al-Shariah had claimed responsibility on social media.” Joe Klein’s view:

It does seem that the Administration’s talking points were massaged a bit after the President’s candor [that the attack was an “act of terror”]. This may have been attributable to the presidential campaign and the Administration’s desire to low-ball the Al Qaeda threat. If so, this was a venial, not a mortal, sin. It affected not one life. More likely, though, the wording was scrubbed as a result of the nature of the investigation going on at the time–it may have been deemed premature to announce that it was a pre-meditated act of terror. Perhaps the local militia lucked into a situation where they showed up at the consulate and found very little security protection. Hard to say. There were protests all over the middle east that night, ginned up by jihadis using the excuse of a near-unseen anti-Muslim You Tube video.

But let’s say the street gang had been casing the joint in advance. Who’s to blame for the lax security? This is the real substance of the case. Could it have been the Secretary of State? Undoubtedly, no. This sort of question is well below her pay grade. Could it have been the person in charge of embassy security issues? More likely, and that person resigned after the subsequent investigations…and even that might have been unfair for two reasons. Security was up to the Ambassador and Chris Stevens was well known for erring on the side of greater public access to U.S. facilities. Or, more plausibly, reason number two…

Could it have been the Republicans who consistently voted against funds for increased embassy security? Hmmm…that makes their current carping seem awfully political, doesn’t it?

Hirsh’s bottom line:

There was tragic incompetence, plainly, in the Obama administration’s handling of the Benghazi attacks, and even possibly some political calculation. It is a record that may well come to haunt Hillary Clinton, the first Secretary of State to lose an ambassador in the field in more than three decades, if she runs for president in 2016. But the obvious Republican effort to turn this inquiry into the Democratic (Obama) version of the Iraq intelligence scandal that has tarred the GOP since the George W. Bush years — led by that least-credible of champions, the almost-always-wrong Darrell Issa — is just not going to amount to much.

Which is the only reason we haven’t covered this much. Because what is worth covering has largely been covered; because some in government have already lost their jobs for the incompetence; because we have had nine separate Congressional investigations, while attacks on embassies and consulates in the past have been far less likely to be controversial. In other words: this is now a function entirely of factionalism. It’s a test of how far one cable news channel can go in creating something big out of something tragic, regrettable, well worth looking into, but in the end scarcely scandalous.