Hof, Iceland, 8.56 am
Author: Andrew Sullivan
The Gun Lobby, The Israel Lobby, And Double Standards, Ctd
I recently wrote that “talking about the Israel lobby in exactly the same way that everyone talks about the gun lobby is not and never has been ipso facto anti-Semitism.” Pascal-Emmanuel Gobry doesn’t fully disagree but thinks there are good reasons we treat the lobbying groups differently. The core of his post:
Our society, quite reasonably in my view, has developed a taboo against the use of words associated with group hatred, as a way to stigmatize said hatred. White people can’t use the n word in contemporary polite American society because that word is associated with the memory of white people who used that word and bought and sold black people as chattel… So we stigmatize it … Expressions like “Jewish lobby”, which carries the anti-Semitic trope that Jews are a shadowy clique that secretly controls the government have been — for centuries, around the world, to this very day in some places — used as spurs to mass violence.
This is an important point that lays bare the problem. One of the tropes of anti-Semitism has indeed been the notion that secret, powerful cabals of Jews somehow control the world from behind the curtain. That’s why I think Gobry is right to stigmatize a phrase like the “Jewish lobby” and why Chuck Hagel was right to apologize for that phrase. But “Israel lobby”? Or “Greater Israel lobby”, as I prefer to use? Not so much.
That phrase recognizes the existence of a lobby as powerful as the NRA, and just as distortive of rational public policy. It also recognizes that the Israel and Greater Israel lobbies are increasingly Christianist rather than Jewish, as the Christian fundamentalists in America find common cause with the Jewish fundamentalists on the West Bank. The Americans who show up for new settlement openings are increasingly called Huckabee.
But Gobry won’t even allow for such a neutral phrase:
Yes, phrases like “The Israel Lobby” are redolent of anti-Semitism. Yes, using crypto-anti-Semitic language is stigmatized by any decent society worthy of the name.
This is where I think the rhetorical game is rigged. Note the qualifications: phrases “like the ‘Israel Lobby'”; “redolent of”; “crypto-anti-Semitic”. It reminds me of Leon Wieseltier accusing me of “something much darker” than anti-Semitism, in order to be able to state that he never accused me of being an anti-Semite. It’s bullying blather. But it does have the advantage of making the Israel Lobby the only such lobby to be rendered immune from being described as exercizing control over the Congress like the NRA, even if it does.
This blog will avoid such a double standard for the simple purpose of telling the truth, as I can best discern it.
Selling The Model
Hunter Oatman-Stanford looks at the rise of Calvin Klein underwear:
Interestingly, Calvin Klein’s first range of underwear in the 1980s was made in the same factories as Jockey.
Even though we think that Calvin Klein invented this idea of the brand name in the waistband, Jockey was doing that in the 1950s. But what Klein did was to make the rise slightly lower, to make the fit slightly tighter. …
Through the 1970s, you had this explosion of color and pattern, but Klein went back to a classic simplicity that was reflected in the form of the man in the advertising. So you had this statuesque, athletic body in a very classic, simple, white garment. The question, really, is about what was being sold: Suddenly, men were presented for sale in the way that women had been in advertising. One of Calvin Klein’s biggest impacts wasn’t on underwear but on the presentation of men in popular culture.
Behind The Headlines
“Syria threatens Israel, says airstrikes near Damascus open door to ‘all options’” – Washington Post headline today.
“Israel enforces ‘red line’ with Syria airstrike on weapons bound for Hezbollah, officials say” – Washington Post, on the news that Israel had actually bombed Syria’s capital city.
So Syria “threatens” Israel, but Israel was only “enforcing a red line”. There’s a mindset here that is not exactly open to neutral reporting. The assumption that the US and Israel can do anything militarily with obvious justification, while our enemies are barred from even threatening to retaliate, can become a form of solipsistic blindness.
War is war. We should be as subject to its laws as anyone else. Or we become as lawless as Middle East states’ foreign policies (including Israel’s).
The Heartburn Of Too Many Reviews
Tom Vanderbilt is often afflicted by it:
In the days before the Internet, eating at an unknown restaurant meant relying on a clutch of quick and dirty heuristics. The presence of many truck drivers or cops at a lonely diner supposedly vouchsafed its quality (though it may simply have been the only option around). For “ethnic” food, there was the classic benchmark: “We were the only non-[insert ethnicity] people in there.” Or you could spend anxious minutes on the sidewalk, under the watchful gaze of the host, reading curling, yellowed reviews, wondering if what held in 1987 was still true today. In an information-poor environment, you sometimes simply went with your gut (and left clutching it).
Today, via Yelp (or TripAdvisor or Amazon, or any Web site teeming with “user-generated content”), you are often troubled by the reverse problem: too much information.
As I navigate a Yelp entry to simply determine whether a place is worth my money, I find myself battered between polar extremes of experience: One meal was “to die for,” another “pretty lame.” Drifting into narrow currents of individual proclivity (writing about a curry joint where I had recently lunched, one reviewer noted that “the place had really good energy, very Spiritual [sic], which is very important to me”), I eventually capsize in a sea of confusion. I either quit the place altogether or, by the time I arrive, am weighed down by a certain exhaustion of expectation, as if I had already consumed the experience and was now simply going through the motions.
Recent Dish on the “paradox of choice” here.
(Screenshot of prison reviews on Yelp)
Yes, Of Course It Was Jihad, Ctd
Moynihan investigates Islamic extremism on the web:
I decided to try an experiment: I would spend seven days creeping through the Internet using disposable IP addresses, inhabiting the milieu of radical sites and Facebook pages. In Manhattan coffee shops, on subway platforms, between tasks at work, I would take up residence in the darkest corners of the Web—and see what I could learn about the fetid swamps where self-made jihadists are allegedly born.
His big takeaway? It works – by numbing followers to violence:
The further I crawled down the extremist rabbit hole and the more caved-in skulls and headless corpses I saw, the more I found that my natural revulsion, usually an uncontrollable instinct, was easier to suppress.
And it wasn’t just my revulsion to violence that seemed to dull: the casual Jew hatred, homophobia (yes, there were references to the “sick” revelation that NBA player Jason Collins is gay), and sexism (“The beauty of a woman lies in her SILENCE rather than her SPEECH”) were so eye-glazingly common that after a week of uninterrupted consumption, I found myself scrolling past it without a second thought.
Americans were jarred by a gruesome—and now iconic—photo of Boston Marathon spectator Jeff Bauman being rushed toward an ambulance, one of his legs blown off below the knee. In the universe of electronic jihad, such images are banal. To be a social-media jihadi for a week is to be reminded of French essayist Alain Finkielkraut’s admonition: “Barbarism is not the inheritance of our pre-history. It is the companion that dogs our every step.”
My earlier take on the Boston jihad here.
(Screenshot from the al Qaeda magazine Inspire, supposedly an inspiration to the Boston bombing suspects.)
Journalism In 2013
Ask Josh Fox Anything: Obama’s Support For Natural Gas
The environmental activist and the filmmaker describes what most shocked him while making Gasland Part II:
Readers are starting to dissent over the series:
I haven’t seen Gasland, and until you posted the Q/A with Josh Fox, I didn’t have an opinion about him one way or another. As a resident of NE Ohio, sitting on top of the Utica Shale, I have been following the issues surrounding the exploitation of shale gas, and I’m genuinely undecided on whether the benefits of “fracking” outweigh the risks. Listening to Josh Fox’s responses did nothing to advance my understanding of this complex issue. It’s obvious that Fox isn’t at all interested in presenting a fair (but biased) assessment. No, he’s an activist/filmaker in the mode of Michael Moore, and I suspect Gasland, like Roger and Me or Sicko, is more propaganda than journalism.
Anyone who is paying attention to this issue, and who doesn’t have an ideological ax to grind, knows that the evidence is far from clear concerning the nature and extent of water contamination and methane emissions related to natural gas extraction. But you wouldn’t know it if Fox was your only source. He cites one study by a team from Cornell University for the proposition that fracking will result in greenhouse gas emissions greater than or equal to coal. Ten minutes on the Internet will show you that this doesn’t represent the consensus view on this issue. Far from it: the study to which he refers is highly-disputed and seems to be something of an outlier, and those who have criticized it are not simply gas industry shills (as Fox likes to label his critics), but independent researchers. Same goes for water contamination, where the evidence is nowhere near as clear as Fox makes it out to be. As a non-scientist I can’t independently judge who’s right on the data; but as a lawyer I know a half-baked argument when I see one, and the intellectually dishonest way that Fox presents this issue while ignoring or mischaracterizing contrary evidence gives me pause.
Then there’s his use of a false analogy that equates risk management for passenger air travel to that for natural gas drilling and groundwater contamination.
Fox asks why we would tolerate a 30-50% failure rate for gas well casings when we expect aircraft to be designed and built to operate without catastrophic failures 99.99999% of the time. First, how are these even comparable? A small defect on a critical component of an aircraft can lead to catastrophic failure. What is the risk associated with a cracked well casings, and what is the likelihood that it will lead to a catastrophic failures resulting in human deaths? How do “fracked” well casings differ from conventional well casings with respect to groundwater risks? How often do well casing failures lead to groundwater contamination, and how severe is the contamination? (If there are a million gas wells operating worldwide, and 30-50% of them fail, that’s a lot of poisoned groundwater. You’d think there would have been an uproar about this long ago.) If you’re determined to compare the gas industry to the transportation sector, why pick air travel? As a society we tolerate 40,000 automobile traffic-related deaths each year, plus billions of dollars in property damages. We do this because we’ve determined that the benefits of the automobile vastly outweigh the risks.
Clearly, Fox the activist isn’t much interested in an honest discussion of benefits vs. risks. He simply wants to advance his agenda by appealing to people’s emotions and fears. That’s fine, but I can’t understand why the Dish lets this go without posting some contrary views.
Another contrary view:
I claim no particular expertise on the issue of whether, on balance, increased extraction of natural gas through hydraulic fracturing is a good thing for the environment and our economy, in relation to our current methods of energy generation or other feasible alternatives. I am, however, familiar enough with the debate to know that Josh Fox is at last half-full of shit. For example, he cites “the Cornell study” as if it were undisputed proof that fracking will result in greater greenhouse gas emissions than coal over the short-to-medium term, and that such emissions will be about equal over the long term. Among the experts who were not impressed with the study’s metholodology were several other members of the Cornell faculty (pdf), who concluded:
The data clearly shows that substituting natural gas for coal will have a substantial greenhouse benefit under almost any set of reasonable assumptions. Methane emissions must be five times larger than they currently appear to be before gas substitution for coal becomes detrimental from a global warming perspective on any time scale. The advantage of natural gas applies whether it comes from a shale gas well or a conventional gas well. Scientifically the prescription for reducing green house emissions is clear: substitute gas for coal while minimizing methane emissions using proven and available technology, and then move toward low carbon energy sources as quickly as technically and economically feasible.
For Fox to cherry-pick one highly disputed study, and not even acknowledge that it doesn’t represent a consensus view among experts, is intelluctually dishonest. So, by the way, is the slimy way he attempts to conflate the natural gas industry with the tobacco business by noting that their respective trade groups used the same PR firm, Edelman. So the fuck what? Edelman has represented thousand of companies. Does Fox want to equate Starbucks, Heinz, Butterball Turkeys and Samsung with Big Tobacco?
Josh Fox’s Gasland Part II will air on HBO this summer. His other Ask Anything answers are here. Full AA archive here.
The Skyline From Below
In his series “Verical Horizon,” photographer Romain Jacquet-Lagreze captures upward-looking views of Hong Kong skyscrapers:
[Jacquet-Lagreze‘s] interest in photography began during his period of working in Los Angeles and Tokyo, and subsequently blossomed into a passion after his arrival in Hong Kong. Stunned by its architectural “race to the sky”, he felt the need to use his camera to share his feelings about the city. The geometry of the urban environment and the vivid lives it shelters are the aspects of Hong Kong that inspire him most.
More amazing photographs here.
(Photo: from Vertical Horizon, published by Asia One, 2012)
Yes, Of Course It Was Jihad, Ctd
A couple of points that may inform two long-running debates between me and Glenn Greenwald. The first is the motive for the Boston bombings. Of course, we should always wait for the full evidence, and there is always an interplay between a particular psychological journey and religious fanaticism. I’ve said that from the get-go. But we can now pretty safely say – as we could pretty quickly – that the bombings were an almost text-book case of Internet Jihad, a chilling example of how fundamentalist zeal can become murderous right here in our midst, with no necessary international network.
Money quote from a profile of Dzhokhar:
After Mr. Tsarnaev emerged as a suspect in the bombing, Mr. Lamichhane said, a mutual friend from the University of Massachusetts recounted his last conversation with Mr. Tsarnaev, two weeks before the marathon. Mr. Tsarnaev told their friend, “God is all that matters. It doesn’t matter about school and engineering,” Mr. Lamichhane said. “He said, ‘When it comes to school and being an engineer, you can cheat easily. But when it comes to going to heaven, you can’t cheat.’ ”
Five words: “God is all that matters.” If some secular liberals could grasp that a modern human can say those words and mean them, they would have a better grasp of our core predicament. The religious conversion was relatively recent – and had an obvious effect:
A second Chechen friend since boyhood, 18-year-old Baudy Mazaev, said that the older brother and their mother, Zubeidat Tsarnaeva, “had a deep religious epiphany” about two or three years ago. At the time, Tamerlan’s new devotion only irritated Dzhokhar, he said. During one visit about two years ago, he said, Tamerlan ordered him and Dzhokhar to sit and forced the two teenagers to read a book about the fundamentals of Islam and prayer… In February 2011, roughly when the boys’ mother embraced Islam, she separated from her husband, Anzor, a tough man trained in the law in Russia who was reduced in Cambridge to fixing cars in a parking lot. The two divorced that September, and Anzor returned to Russia, followed later by his ex-wife. Tamerlan filled the void as head of the family’s American branch. On Twitter, Dzhokhar wrote that he missed his father.
Fundamentalism took over that family. It drove the father away. The second point worth noting (and relevant to a debate Glenn and I have conducted) is the man who personally seemed to have inspired and help train the Tsarnaev brothers from the grave – Anwar al Awlaki:
Two U.S. officials tell The Daily Beast that, during his hospital room interrogation, Dzhokhar told FBI agents that he and his brother were influenced by the Internet sermons of Anwar al-Awlaki, the American-born preacher who was killed in a U.S. drone strike in Yemen in September 2011…
We know Awlaki influenced the Tsarnaevs at least indirectly, through one of AQAP’s main propaganda organs. According to law enforcement sources, Dzhokhar has admitted to the FBI that he and his brother learned how to the build pressure cooker bombs they allegedly used in Boston from the terror group’s English-language Internet magazine, Inspire. For much of its existence, Inspire was run by Samir Khan, an American propagandist for AQAP who was close to Awlaki and was ultimately killed in the same U.S. drone strike that killed the Yemeni-American cleric.
It seems to me that Anwar al-Awlaki was clearly complicit in the Boston marathon bombers and that the bulk of his propaganda was about inciting domestic terrorism in the US along the Tsarnaev lines. That makes him a little more than an icon for the First Amendment. It makes him a traitor allied with forces that want to kill American citizens.





