The Weekend Wrap

800px-Oxalis_corymbosa_2

This weekend on the Dish, Andrew addressed Niall Ferguson’s offensive comments about John Maynard Keynes’ homosexuality, following-up by musing on quotes from both Burke and Keynes on capitalism.

We also provided our usual eclectic mix religious, books, and cultural coverage. In matters of faith, doubt, and philosophy, Simon Willis argued particularism was the best philosophy, Molly Crockett debated the ethics of a “morality pill,” and Tim Kreider embraced doubt. Damon Linker found Christ in Malick’s To the Wonder, David Sessions grappled with losing his religion, and Jonathan Fitzgerald excoriated a Christianity Today piece on hip-hop. Roger Tagholm pondered the effects of holy books going digital, Russell D. Moore eulogized country singer George Jones, and Frans de Waal challenged Christian assumptions about animals. Patrick Kurp outgrew his resistance to talking about his heroes, Claire Messud pondered our contradictory natures, and John Berryman reflected on the connection between suffering and creativity.

In literary and arts coverage, Olive Senior thought literature couldn’t help but be political, Mason Currey chronicled the chemical lives of great writers, and Tony Woodlief defended the democratization of art. D.G. Myers observed a paradox in understanding literature, Nathaniel Rich considered the despair he found in the novel Miss Lonelyhearts, and Andrew O’Hagan contemplated writers whose work was informed by another medium. Thom Yorke divulged his ideal of beauty, the pacifist author of Winnie the Pooh struggled with his wartime conscription, and Maria Bustillos penned a love letter to her favorite highway. Read Saturday’s poem here and Sunday’s here.

In assorted news and views, Brian Eno expounded on his vintage pornography collection, Helen Lewis visited a collection of harvested tattoos, and Jonathan Harris described the moments of unexpected intimacy caught on film between pornstars. Maria Popova pointed to a great list from Susan Sontag, Miles Raymer assessed the unlikely success of the band Neutral Milk Hotel, and a member of Alcoholic Anonymous developed a strange alternative therapy for the disease. Robert W. Gehl wondered if there is any hope for haters, the Internet proved to be for marriage, and a profile of an electronic cigarette revealed how advertisers try to brand what’s bad for you. Malkin Award nominee here, MHBs here and here, FOTDs here and here, VFYWs here and here, and the latest window contest here.

– M.S.

(Photo: “Oxalis debilis Kunth varietas corymbosa (DC.) Lourteig, 1981″ via Wikipedia)

The Suburbia Genre, Ctd

dish_RHP_Anonymization

Ian Stansel examines it:

[H]ow can we not feel the pangs of existential anxiety when the national—and indeed human—drive to distinguish oneself from one’s neighbor comes into conflict with the simultaneous values of suburban uniformity? Their economic comfort does not prevent us from feeling for these suburban characters; we relate all too well to the dual struggles for belonging and individual identity.

“Economic circumstances might force you to live in this environment,” [Richard] Yates writes in his 1961 masterpiece [Revolutionary Road], “but the important thing was to keep from being contaminated. The important thing, always, was to remember who you were.” A strange quote. The “economic circumstances” spoken of here, when taking a larger view of the world, involve being relatively well off. And “contamination” may seem a bit melodramatic in the light of significant poverty and struggle found across the globe.

But this is what so much literature is about: yearning for something beyond the material. Love. Honor. Empathy. Knowledge. And in the case of the suburban novel, identity. Even in books where there is a mortal danger to the protagonists, they have something more at stake. Living is not enough. The characters ache for a connection to their own humanity. Also from Yates:

Look what happens when a man really does blow his top. Call the Troopers, get him out of sight quick, hustle him off and lock him up before he wakes the neighbors…The hell with reality! Let’s have a whole bunch of cute little winding roads and cute little houses painted white and pink and baby blue; let’s all be good consumers and have a lot of Togetherness and bring our children up in a bath of sentimentality—and if old reality ever does pop out and say Boo we’ll all get busy and pretend it never happened.

It is the desire of these characters to be human, completely and unapologetically, with all the confusion and contradictions and insecurity that that entails, all the depressions and elations and deaths and births and malodorous bodily functions—and yet still belong to the order of the community. We all struggle to exist as multiple selves that are often at odds with each other: parent and child; teacher and student; healer and disciplinarian; warrior and peacemaker; insider and outsider. The suburbs represent this precarious and ultimately unsustainable equilibrium.

Previous Dish on suburban fiction here.

(Photo: Robert Harding Pittman, Lake Las Vegas Resort | Las Vegas, USA, from book and exhibition project “Anonymization“)

Should We Kill Cursive? Ctd

Contribute your two cents to the growing thread:

This embed is invalid

A reader writes:

Is it that Polikoff and Gladstone are under the impression that teaching children to write in cursive somehow takes up too much time? Or that children are vessels into which we can only fit so much, and therefore we should not try to teach them anything “unnecessary”? Pure hogwash on both counts. Learning to write legibly and speedily by hand is, in my own humble experience, invaluable. Any endeavor that requires note-taking in any real degree, especially in real time, becomes immensely more easy and pleasurable if one writes well in cursive, and it’s much faster than “print” letters.

And think about the utilitarian logic of not teaching “unnecessary” things to children. Should we not teach them music, drawing, singing, dancing, sports or any other of the manifold pursuits that give life depth and richness but do not technically serve any real economic purpose? Preposterous.

Furthermore, writing well and attractively by hand deepens our engagement with our language, instills respect for the written word, and frankly just looks better, in my opinion. It also isn’t really very hard. Like most worthwhile things, it just takes practice. And I reject this silly sophistry that says making things beautiful, and teaching kids to do simple, humble things like writing nicely is something we don’t have the resources or time to give them. Instilling in them a deep sense of craft, and of craftsmanship, is in fact of the highest importance.

Another reader who defends cursive:

The greatest lesson I ever learned came from an idealistic young woman who spent a year in the late sixties teaching sixth grade at the American Community School in Hampstead between gigs with the Peace Corps.  When asked by a fellow student why we were studying a seemingly insignificant thing, she replied, “You’re not here to learn stuff.  You’re here to practice how to learn stuff, because no matter how old you get, you will always need to learn.”

Another:

Cursive, as it’s taught in schools now, was actually not intended to be for handwriting.  “Looped cursive,” with its letters that look nothing like print, originally comes from letterforms inscribed FontinAustraliaby copperplate engravers.  Credit for this knowledge goes to Barbara Getty and Inga Dubay, calligraphers who for years have had a side gig running handwriting improvement workshops for doctors!  They also take issue with the “ball and stick” method of teaching print handwriting, as each letter often requires two or more strokes, and advocate instead for italic-style handwriting, which is much more natural (I’ve attached the best comparison I can find).  As an added bonus, italic handwriting easily transitions into cursive.

Who knows if any of this will be relevant in the digital age, but apparently the difficulty of writing in cursive also assists memory.

The Inevitability Of Art

https://twitter.com/Bitchuation/status/328651669543976961

The following passage is from a speech that director Steven Soderbergh recently gave at the 56th San Francisco International Film Festival:

Given all the incredible suffering in the world I wonder, what is art for, really? If the collected works of Shakespeare can’t prevent genocide then really, what is it for? Shouldn’t we be spending the time and resources alleviating suffering and helping other people instead of going to the movies and plays and art installations? When we did Ocean’s Thirteen the casino set used $60,000 of electricity every week. How do you justify that? Do you justify that by saying, the people who could’ve had that electricity are going to watch the movie for two hours and be entertained – except they probably can’t, because they don’t have any electricity, because we used it. Then I think, what about all the resources spent on all the pieces of entertainment? What about the carbon footprint of getting me here? Then I think, why are you even thinking that way and worrying about how many miles per gallon my car gets, when we have NASCAR, and monster truck pulls on TV? So what I finally decided was, art is simply inevitable.

It was on the wall of a cave in France 30,000 years ago, and it’s because we are a species that’s driven by narrative. Art is storytelling, and we need to tell stories to pass along ideas and information, and to try and make sense out of all this chaos. And sometimes when you get a really good artist and a compelling story, you can almost achieve that thing that’s impossible which is entering the consciousness of another human being – literally seeing the world the way they see it. Then, if you have a really good piece of art and a really good artist, you are altered in some way, and so the experience is transformative and in the minute you’re experiencing that piece of art, you’re not alone.

Though Soderbergh has retired from filmmaking, his artistic energy is being used to tweet a novella from an account called Bitchuation: 

Written in second-person, “Glue” follows a yet-unnamed protagonist (“you”) to the underworld of Amsterdam and Paris, where the mysterious substance “#&%#” is coveted “because everyone wanted it and nobody had it.” Uniquely, Soderbergh also works in visual elements to his pulp fiction narrative. Photos accompany some of the tweets; establishing shots, per se, that also serve to set the mood. Crooked photos of buildings. Smudgy faces glimpsed from the corner of an intoxicated eye.

[W]hat makes “Glue” utterly brilliant is its parodying of the tradition of hardboiled pulp fiction. Using the clipped sentences and the weighty delivery one instantly associates with Raymond Chandler, “Glue” can at once seem satirical, gimmicky or earnest, playing with a tradition so overwrought with material that its almost unrecognizable in its plainest form to a modern reader.

Seeing Ourselves In Other Species

Primatologist Frans de Waal, writing in the newly launched Nautilus magazine, challenges Christian assumptions about animals:

It’s an old Christian idea that humans have souls and animals don’t. I sometimes think it’s because our religions arose in a desert environment in which there were no primates, so you have people who lived with camels, goats, snakes, and scorpions. Of course, you then conclude that we are totally different from the rest of the animal kingdom because we don’t have primates with whom to compare ourselves. When the first great apes arrived in Western Europe—to the zoos in London and Paris—people were absolutely flabbergasted. Queen Victoria even expressed her disgust at seeing these animals. Why would an ape be disgusting unless you feel a threat from it? You would never call a giraffe disgusting, but she was disgusted by chimpanzees and orangutans because people had no concept that there could be animals so similar to us in every possible way. We come from a religion that’s not used to that kind of comparison.

His new book The Bonobo and the Atheist tackles religion more broadly:

I don’t think primates have religions, but they may have certain superstitions. For example, if a thunderstorm comes through with an enormous amount of noise and rain, male chimpanzees will put their hands up and start walking around bipedally, in a dancing sort of fashion. It’s called a rain dance and it has been observed with chimpanzees approaching a waterfall. We really don’t know why they do it. Are they impressed by what happens? Do they think they can stop it? Of course, that would be superstition. Are they somehow in awe of nature?

Previous Dish on de Waal here.

Quote For The Day II

“I do strongly feel that among the greatest pieces of luck for high achievement is ordeal. Certain great artists can make out without it, Titian and others, but mostly you need ordeal. My idea is this: The artist is extremely lucky who is presented with the worst possible ordeal which will not actually kill him. At that point, he’s in business. Beethoven’s deafness, Goya’s deafness, Milton’s blindness, that kind of thing. And I think that what happens in my poetic work in the future will probably largely depend not on my sitting calmly on my ass as I think, “Hmm, hmm, a long poem again? Hmm,” but on being knocked in the face, and thrown flat, and given cancer, and all kinds of other things short of senile dementia. At that point, I’m out, but short of that, I don’t know. I hope to be nearly crucified,” – John Berryman.

Face Of The Day

Children Become Buddhist Monks

A child rubs his head after a Buddhist monk shaved his hair off during the ‘Children Becoming Buddhist Monks’ ceremony, in advance of Buddha’s birthday, at a Chogye temple on May 3, 2013 in Seoul, South Korea. The children will stay at the temple to learn about Buddhism for 14 days. Buddha was born approximately 2,557 years ago, and although the exact date is unknown, Buddha’s official birthday is celebrated on the full moon in May in South Korea, which is on May 17 this year. By Chung Sung-Jun/Getty Images.

Quote For The Day

“I’ve spent the past week—as I’ve spent much of the past few years—wanting only for the world to go away, for all engagements to be canceled, and to have more time with my family. It’s almost as if the desire for community is a nostalgic one; and the reality, with time’s winged chariot hurrying near, is that one longs increasingly for simple affections, for space, and calm, and time to work. What contradictory beings humans are,” – Claire Messud.

Should Literature Be Political?

Olive Senior argues it can’t be avoided:

We are all enmeshed in politics because we are all citizens of somewhere – even writers – and we cannot escape being shaped by political decisions, big and small. So instead of asking the question “Should literature be political?”, I would rephrase it as a statement: Literature is political because we, the creators of literature, are political animals; it is part of accepting our responsibility of being human, of being citizens of the world …

Every author has a world view which reflects a political stance and shapes what we do, even unconsciously. For example, as a child, I grew up in a world where I never saw myself or the people around me visually portrayed in the children’s books I read (though I took great pleasure in reading them). As a writer of children’s books now, I would say that I am simply concerned with telling a story that a child anywhere in the world that might want to read. But, I have to confess, I am very much concerned that the illustrations should reflect and express a multicultural world, for that is what I live in. Is that political? Can any of us escape the political? I would say no. Even romantic literature plunges us into the realm of political economy: does the potential suitor have a job?

Hating On Christian Hip-Hop

Christianity Today got the President-elect of the Southern Baptist Ethics & Religious Liberty Commission, Russell Moore, to write their May cover story on Christianity and hip-hop, replete the with cringe-inducing title of “W.W. Jay-Z?” Here’s the question that the article begins with (the rest is behind their paywall):

The violent edge of rap—”it’s just so angry”—is most often what I hear behind American Christians’ ambivalence about the new wave of Christian hip-hop. But not all of this ambivalence is reactionary, revealing white-bread taste. It’s a real question: Can one authentically rap the Sermon on the Mount, with its Beatitudes, warnings against anger, and meekness? No doubt one can set Matthew 5–7 to rhyme and meter, but would it still be hip-hop? If not, does that rule hip-hop out as legitimate Christian art?

Jonathan Fitzgerald unloads on the piece:

To put it plainly, May’s cover story, “W.W. Jay-Z,” written by Dr. Russell Moore is an unmitigated disaster. And that’s to say nothing of the misleading — but attention-grabbing — title on the cover, “Why the Gospel Needs Hip-Hop.” It is so horrendous that, upon reading it, I knew immediately I had to respond, but I couldn’t figure out where to begin or how to go about responding.

One of Fitzgerald’s objections is that Moore neglects the history of Christian hip-hop:

Although Moore refers several times to the contemporary crop of Christian rappers as “new,” he shows no evidence that he’s aware of what was “old.” In fact, I’m not even sure after re-reading several times if he is calling the whole phenomenon of Christian rap new, or just this most recent manifestation. But let’s give him the benefit of the doubt and hope that he’s just saying that Lecrae and Shai Linne and Trip Lee and their ilk are the newest brand of a Christian hip-hop culture that is just about as old as hip-hop in general. But if he knows this to be true, why not mention this long lineage? How can you have a meaningful conversation about the interplay between gospel message and rap music without looking at those who have both succeeded gloriously and failed miserably before this most recent crop?

If he had any knowledge of those that came before, the question of whether or not the gospel can be communicated through rap lyrics would be moot. He could have skipped that question altogether and looked instead at the ways it has been done. If he wanted to see his bias about rap being bolstered by threat of retaliation, he could have looked at how Christian groups like Gospel Gangstaz, T-Bone, and C.M.C’s (among others), appropriated (badly, as if that wasn’t obvious) the “gangsta” style for Christ. But from there, he would have had to acknowledge that there’s not just one feeling of rap music, and as such, Christian rap groups ended up being quite diverse, particularly through what I call the golden age of Christian hip-hop, the mid- to late-90s. Good luck trying to group LA Symphony, Tunnel Rats, Grits, or Cross Movement under one general “feeling.”