Quote For The Day III

“I believe we are at the end of what church historians will, in the future, call the Billy Graham era… I believe we are also nearing the end of the ‘Religious Right’ representing Evangelicalism… My prayer is that over the next 10 years, there will be a Love Reformation and the Gospel will retake the Bible-believing church," – the tweets of Ted Haggard.

Live-Tweeting A Firing Squad, Ctd

A reader writes:

I have long advocated that executions be televised. Networks would not do it, but public access channels should. Some people think this particularly gruesome of me. I suspect those are the same people who though the Utah attorney general’s remarks were shameless or callous. We could debate about whether the death penalty is ethical or not. But what seems clear to me is that the people should know what is being done in their name. Executions used to routinely be public several decades ago, and the people knew exactly what was being done in their name.

If the people of Utah could see the executions, and they were horrified, they would demand change, and executions would stop. If the people of Utah are not horrified by the executions, then the attorney general’s comments are a small matter. In any event, his comments take the state a step further in making sure the people know what is being done in their name, and hence should be perceived as a positive thing.

Another writes:

Were other witnesses allowed to text from the execution chamber?

(I suspect not; I'm sure everyone had their phones confiscated so no pictures or messages could be sent.) Is the state the only entity allowed to communicate from there? Could a condemned prisoner's family or supporters, unconvinced of his/her guilt, be allowed to tweet a counter-narrative? Now that it's been opened up to communication devices, is the Utah execution room considered a "public forum" where the government allows communications but cannot censor its content?

Perhaps one of your readers who's an expert on constitutional law could evaluate whether the AG – in what to my mind looks like a cheap ploy to look both tough and devout – has opened a Pandora's box for death penalty advocates.

BP’s Damage Control, Ctd

BP-fail-whale

First newspapers, then Google searches, now social networking sites. Alex Seitz-Wald isn't impressed:

… BP seems uninterested in the social aspect of social media. On Facebook, the company only accepts comments from people who “like” BP, while comments are disabled completely on the company’s YouTube channel

("BP fail whale" illustration by Oskar Krawczyk)

McChrystal Must Go? Ctd

Andrew Exum runs through the pros and cons:

In the end, your opinion on whether or not Gen. McChrystal should be dismissed might come down to whether or not you think the current strategy is the correct one for the war in Afghanistan. My own prediction is that Gen. McChrystal will be retained. As much as critics of counterinsurgency like to blame Gen. McChrystal (and nefarious think-tankers, of course) for the current strategy, the reality is that the civilian decision-makers in the Obama Administration conducted two high-level reviews in 2009 and twice arrived at a national strategy focused on conducting counterinsurgency operations in Afghanistan. I suspect the president will not replace the man he has put in charge of executing that strategy with just 12 months to go before we begin a withdrawal.

Goldblog sides with Joe Klein:

I remember once in Iraq being made to feel profoundly uncomfortable by an Army colonel who was openly scornful of President Bush's tactical leadership of the war effort (this was well-before the surge). I didn't disagree with his analysis one bit, but I thought it was deeply inappropriate, and even nervous-making, to hear a senior military leader disparaging his commander. Civilian control of the military is a paramount American virtue, and anyone who undermines this core principle is unfit to serve. There's no way around this fundamental fact, unfortunately. 

Tom Ricks bets McChrystal will be gone in a week or two:

My nomination is for Petraeus to step down an echelon and take the Afghanistan command. You could leave him nominally the Centcom chief but let his deputy, Marine Lt. Gen. John Allen, oversee Iraq, the war planning for Iran, and dealing with Pakistan and the Horn of Africa. But more likely is that Petraeus will ask for another Marine general, James Mattis, who is just finishing up at Jiffycom, and who had planned to retire later this year and head home to Walla Walla, Washington. Petraeus and Mattis long have admired each other. The irony is that Mattis has a reputation — unfairly, I think — for speaking a little too bluntly in public about things like killing people. I think Mattis is a terrific, thoughtful leader.  

My gut tells me Ricks is right.

The VFYW Contest: Winner #3

Vfyw-contest-6-19

A reader writes:

So those pretty unique mountain formations immediately make one think of Southern China or Vietnam. But seeing as I’m getting to this particular contest 24 hours late and many guesses that fall within China and Vietnam have probably already been submitted, I think my best bet of winning this book is to cross my fingers and hope this was taken somewhere else in the region. It’s clearly an urban space, blue bus public transportation and all. I’m going to take a wild stab in the dark and say Phnom Penh, Cambodia.

Another writes:

I believe this one is from Rio de Janeiro. Or, perhaps to be more precise, Niteroi, Brazil (which lies across the bay from Rio). I believe I can see the famous statue of Christ the Redeemer in one of the mountains.

Another:

I first saw AC units like that in China, so I’m thinking it’s there, and likely in the southern part of the country. A bit of a stab in the dark, but Suzhou? (Looking forward to laughing in a couple of days when I find out I guessed the wrong continent.)

Right continent. Another:

The hills in the background of the photo remind me of the ones in coastal southwestern Turkey (but they also remind me of China, so who knows).  I’m going to guess Fethiye, Turkey for the heck of it – also because the white building on the right also reminds me of Turkish construction.

Another:

This is clearly China.  The mountains in the background are a dead giveaway. I am amused at myself for recognizing this based on Art History classes in Chinese landscape painting from many, many years ago.  Beyond that I need to guess; I pick Huangshan.

Warm. Another:

I’m probably the hundredth person to guess this, but Vietnam, Halong Bay?  (Beautiful place, but the tourist scene is out of control and really detracts from the experience. Still, it’s a must if you’re ever in Vietnam. It really is one of the wonders of the world.)

About 20 people did guess Halong Bay, but no dice. Another:

I think this may be Guilin, China. I went there on holiday with my family when I was 14 (am now 21). A guy in our group had been there in the ’70s and remembered local people holding their children up to the window of the restaurant he was eating in. They’d never seen a white man before. If it’s not Guilin, then this little story is fairly pointless. Still, beats looking out of my own window in Abingdon, UK. Industrial estates leave much to be desired.

Guilin is getting warmer. Another:

This is most likely spectacularly wrong, but the only place I’ve ever seen the shape of mountains like those is Jackson Hole, WY.  So that’s my guess:  Jackson Hole, WY.

Spectacularly wrong. This reader nails it down:

Is it Yangshuo, China?  If it is, it took only one guess (China) and one Google image search (chinese mountains) to get it right.  Thank Google!

About 50 readers also got Yangshuo (a third of the 600 entries correctly guessed Guilin, but Yangshuo is the more specific political division). The first reader to do so was D.I., who wrote:

Yangshuo in Guilin Province, China, on the Li River. Just a guess based on the karst mountains.

Another reader explains:

Rain water and ground water are slightly acidic and will dissolve carbonate rocks. In Missouri, we get caves. In China, it results in spectacular pinnacles.

Congrats to D.I.!  Next contest goes up Saturday at noon.