McCain And Iraq

Ross thinks I am presenting false choices on Iraq:

There are certainly people for whom the debate over troop levels in Iraq is ultimately about whether American foreign policy gets set on a more explicitly imperialist trajectory, and there’s no question that such voices will be more empowered under a McCain Administration than by a President Obama. The question is whether the likely practical results of a McCain Presidency – a Presidency that will be constrained by all kinds of factors, foreign and domestic – will so empower the Boot vision of America’s role in the world (which I do not share) as to make a vote for McCain a vote for Boot. The alternative, which seems more plausible to me, is that a vote for McCain under these circumstances is a vote for something [more] modest: Namely, a reduction in U.S. forces in Iraq that will proceed more gradually than the reduction Obama is promising, and that will leave the long-term question of the size and scope of America’s entanglement in the Middle East for future administrations to wrestle with.

I sure hope that’s the case. But there are so many hardcore new American century neocons around McCain that I doubt it. One thing I have learned these past few years is that there is no longer any moderating instinct within neoconservatism. It has become an absolutist ideology, which is why its cooptation of the word "conservatism" is so repellent. Give them an inch, and they’ll take a country.

Give them four more years, and we simply cannot know what new wars they will start or new powers they will accrue. If you keep in power people who believe a post-surge lull in Iraq is vindication for the whole project, that torture is a "no-brainer", and that the executive makes its own laws, you cannot assume a middle course.

A McCain-Hagel Republicanism is one thing; a McCain-Lieberman Republicanism is quite another. Until McCain explicitly states he wants all US troops out of Iraq as soon as he deems prudent – all of them – the neocon threat of wider and wider conflict remains. I gave them the benefit of the doubt once. Never again.

HRC And The HIV Travel Ban

I’ve gone to the Human Rights Campaign’s website looking for what they’re doing, how they’re helping lobby for what could be the most important policy change in this Congress, how well they are informing their membership. Alas, the last reference I can find is from March. The issue goes unmentioned in the week’s news. It is absent from their "Press Room." On the page that deals with immigration, there is no mention of the HIV ban. They did not include the issue on their candidates’ questionnaire this year. It’s enough to make you scream.

Nonetheless, they have been helpful in lobbying for the repeal of the HIV travel and immigration ban, working closely with Smith’s and Kerry’s office, and all of us dedicated to removing this anachronism are grateful. Where HRC has failed is in not bringing this issue to the fore sooner, not informing their members better, not making the public case, something that could and should have been done years ago. They can and must do better – but on the lobbying front, they’ve helped move this along once the momentum was there. Credit where it’s due.

As for the latest, the Republican rump blocked a unanimous consent option this morning, and so the vote won’t happen till after the July 4 recess. The odds are looking a lot brighter – thanks in part to your help. But this is the Hill and anything can happen, so emailing your Senator on the HIV ban, if you haven’t, could still help. Here’s the contact list. A quick message asking them to end the HIV travel and immigration ban is all that’s needed.

Iraq = Germany, Ctd.

Two responses from readers:

Is Max Boot completely loony? Does he not realize that a significant reason we needed to stay in Germany and Japan for so long was because we did not want them to rearm and threaten their neighbors and the world again? In Iraq, we are willing participants in re-arming the nation.  We want them to be a threat to their neighbors. So we should be able to leave when they are.

But not if the real goal was to establish an occupying US force to attack Iran. And:

The Iraq war rationalizers repeatedly use the Germany-Japan-Korea argument to justify our remaining in Iraq as if there are clear and unequivocal historical parallels between the two when none exist beyond the fact of our invading the damn countries and then occupying them.  To draw a parallel on this basis when no evidence exists to support it amounts to ignoring the basic laws of physics.  A more relevant parallel would be that of the British occupation of Iraq post World War I but somehow that never gets brought up.   And we wonder why history keeps repeating itself.

The neocons never mention the British occupation of Iraq in the last century. The reason is obvious. Even experts at imperialism were defeated by the "ungrateful volcano" we now plan to sit on top of for ever.

The Living Constitution

Guns

Conservatives win one. Jack Balkin on Heller:

Despite its long and occasionally dreary originalist exegesis, the Heller majority is not really defending the values of 1791. It is enforcing the values of 2008. This is no accident. Indeed, the result in Heller would have been impossible without the success of the conservative movement and the work of the NRA and other social movement actors who, over a period of about 35 years, succeeded in changing Americans’ minds about the meaning of the Second Amendment, and made what were previously off-the-wall arguments about the Constitution socially and politically respectable to political elites. This is living constitutionalism in action.

Could The President Legally Bury Someone Alive?

John Yoo wouldn’t answer yesterday. But his answer has to be yes, right? Here he is in another venue:

"Cassel: If the president deems that he’s got to torture somebody, including by crushing the testicles of the person’s child, there is no law that can stop him?

Yoo: No treaty

Cassel: Also no law by Congress — that is what you wrote in the August 2002 memo…

Yoo: I think it depends on why the President thinks he needs to do that…"