Some Clintonites are hanging in.
Category: The Dish
The Next Conservative Generation
If you read the Dish, you’ll know who they are:
These writers grew up reading conservative classics — Burke, Hayek, Smith, C.S. Lewis — but have now splayed off in all sorts of quirky ideological directions.
There are dozens of writers I could put in this group, but I’d certainly mention Yuval Levin, Daniel Larison, Will Wilkinson, Julian Sanchez, James Poulos, Megan McArdle, Matt Continetti and, though he’s a tad older, Ramesh Ponnuru.
Like the blogosphere itself, it’s an open group. And the only criterion for membership is a modem.
Polling Update
The Time poll is much less dramatic than Newsweek’s or Bloomberg’s. And Gallup shows a tie. In Time’s poll, independents are split equally, but Latinos have moved heavily into Obama’s column. McCain’s national security strength is settling down:
When asked who "would best protect the U.S. against terrorism," 53% of respondents chose McCain to just 33% for Obama. And nearly half, 48% to Obama’s 38%, trusted McCain to handle the war in Iraq, though 57% said they believed the U.S. was wrong to invade Iraq and 56% said they would like to see the troops brought home within the next two years.
“Progressive” Taxation
Okay, let’s go there. John Schwenkler writes:
…the realities of day-to-day life for many poorer rural Americans, who rely especially heavily on automobile travel and lack real public transportation options, mean that taxes on gasoline are straightforwardly regressive. The wealthy have alternatives: they can, if they live in higher-density areas, take the train or the bus, or they can buy more fuel-efficient cars, or they can switch jobs or telecommute. But those living in tiny houses in rural Alabama and driving tens of miles to low-paying factory jobs have no such options, which means that it is likely that they will end up paying the lion’s share of a gasoline tax in terms of both relative and – perhaps – absolute income as well. If progressive taxation is “immoral” (and does Andrew really think that??), levying especially high taxes on purchases that are disproportionately inescapable parts of the lives of the rural poor is downright evil.
For the record, I was talking about higher gas prices not taxes in the post John mentions. But he does get to a core philosophical disagreement here, one that puts me, I know, far out in right-field. To put it as plainly as I can: I don’t believe in a governmental attempt to engineer a substantively "fair" society through taxation. I see taxation as a necessary evil to pay for those few social goods that private individuals cannot provide for themselves. And the mode of taxation, in my view, should be as simple and as market-friendly as possible and should treat citizens equally, irrespective of their incomes. I believe in formal equality and a very limited state, not substantive equality and the welfare state. I know this is pie-in-the-sky, given our current Byzantine tax code and the entrenchment of certain socialistic assumptions in our political culture. I don’t expect any radical change any time soon. But I’m not going to enable this kind of thinking without a challenge to it.
So yes: a flat tax so far as possible for as many as possible and no deductions. That’s my goal. How that differentially impacts the lives of citizens should not be government’s primary concern.
Government’s primary concern is to raise money as efficiently and as leanly and as equally as possible. I’m happy with the government then setting up programs to assist the poor, to provide better education for those at the bottom, safety-net healthcare and better policing. i.e. to gear spending toward social ends that might help the poor the most. These are measurable, practical goods. What I’m not happy with is the assumption that tax policy should really be about redistributing wealth, and engineering substantive economic outcomes. Yes, of course, at lower income levels, a 20 percent flat income tax will be more onerous proportionally than at higher incomes. So what? Why should that even concern a government that is not aiming to socially engineer more substantive equality? and the alternative – skewing taxes to target success – is an absurd set of incentives to put into a growing society.
Am I heartless? I hope not. I just don’t believe that having a heart is what government should be about. It’s what the rest of us should be about. This, of course, is my core disagreement with Obama who does indeed have a notion that government has a right and a duty to take money away from those whom he believes can "afford" it and give it to those who "deserve" it. I don’t believe in a government with that much power and that lofty a social goal. It’s also in part a disagreement with my friends, Ross and Reihan, who see government as integral to guiding the behavior and lives of the working poor.
Look: I may be perpared to give Obama a shot after the last eight years, which combined the worst parts of the left – "compassionate conservatism" – with the worst parts of the moralistic, authoritarian right. I may even think that many of Ross’s and Reihan’s initiatives have merit for a political party that wants to build a majority. But my heart lies with Ron Paul. Always will.
Bad Hair Day?
How about a bad hair life? There’s a rare disorder that goes by the name "incombable hair syndrome." I promise I’m not making it up:
An abstract from Pediatr Dermatol. 2007 Jul-Aug;24(4):436-8.
A 4-year-old boy was noted to have unruly, spangled hair, which could not be combed flat. His mother reported that his hair had always had that texture and that it seemed to grow slowly. A hair pull test demonstrated that hairs could not be easily extracted, and light microscopic examination of the hair revealed pathognomonic characteristics of uncombable hair syndrome, including a triangular cross-sectional shape and canal-like longitudinal depressions.
Enviro-Style
Rob Horning expands upon Megan’s argument about morality being a luxury good:
For most consumers, the sleek design and the product’s environmental perks are of the same ilk—distinctive qualities that mark the consumer who uses such a product as being of a better class. Environmentalism is not a ethos but a design quirk. This may be the only way to corral individuals into acting on a problem that is far too large for any one person’s actions to affect—to ignore outcomes and sell it on style.
Steering The Poor To The GOP
Tyler Cowen on Ross and Reihan’s new book:
The broader vision is that the Republicans can and must find a way to be more friendly to the non-rich. Personally I don’t see any reason to tie all of this to the Republican Party but I agree with most of their proposals…The deep question is why something like this hasn’t already happened. You’ll find the superficial "Republicans are just pro-corporate crooks" answer from bloggers like Kathy G. Another possibility is that Republicans don’t get much electoral credit for pro-poor initiatives (just as many voters simply won’t believe that "Democrats can be tough"). The more competitive political messaging becomes, the more this constraint binds and so the policies of upward redistribution are more likely to be enacted by Republicans in the resulting political equilibrium. If the authors are to get their way somehow this dynamic must be reversed.
Judgement, Not Loyalty
Larison weighs in on the Israel and Iraq debate:
The problem is not one of divided loyalties, as if Israeli interests are being put first and American interests second, but the mistake of seeing the interests of both states as largely or entirely complementary and almost identical. When Anglophiles made this mistake in 1917 and plunged the U.S. into WWI, they were not exhibiting “divided loyalties,” but had a fundamentally mistaken understanding of what the American interest was. Talk of “divided loyalties” comes up because the interests of any two states are not nearly so close or complementary, and those who conflate the interests of two states can end up making poor judgements about what the national interest of their country really is. In the case of the Iraq war, you did have people, including neoconservatives of various backgrounds, making such a poor judgement because they misunderstood what was in the interest of both the United States and Israel. It is not a question of loyalty, but of judgement. Having first misunderstood and then identified the interests of the two states too closely, they ended up harming both. The real issue is not motives, but the effects of terrible policies.
Face Of The Day
Israeli participants hold up the multi-colored Gay Pride flag together with the national flag during the controversial Gay Pride Parade in Jerusalem, on June 26, 2008. Some 3,500 participants marched down town Jerusalem and were secured by 2,000 police officers due to past years violence from Ultra Orthodox Jews opposing a gay parade in the holy city. By Gali Tibbon/AFP/Getty.
Contra Klein
Reihan responds to Joe:
This is an aspect of the withdrawalist critique that I find particularly frustrating. “Aha! But you didn’t turn Baghdad into a harmonious multifaith enclave of cosmopolitan prosperity! Yet” Right. The history of partitions in divided societies is long and ugly. That said, we don’t exactly think of Greece or Turkey, or even India or Pakistan, as failed states. We consider them troubled states that are fragile in many respects. The question is, is the ethnic cleansing reversible? Even now, over a decade after Dayton, Bosnia remains a divided society. Some refugees have returned home, but many more have not — many more have built new lives in new parts of the country or overseas. But maintaining a single state allows the possibility of long-term reconciliation. Refugees are returning to Iraq, perhaps prematurely. This will be an enduring challenge. Yet it is a challenge that can be managed successfully, provided we don’t abandon the Iraqi state at its most vulnerable point.
I think it’s extremely premature to start talking about Iraq as if its fundamental problems have been solved, just because we have had a breathing space in the conflict long enough to make both withdrawal and a permanent occupation more palatable. I do not believe permanent US bases in Iraq will mean anything but endless war and endless expense. The question now is: how do we get out with as little catastrophe as possible?

