Iraq = Germany, Ctd

Josh Marshall responds to Boot:

…there’s one distinction between the case of Germany and Japan and Iraq today that gets far too little mention. It’s not a matter of culture or religion. It is the fact in the aftermath of World War II, both Germany and Japan had been conquered by the United States and her allies in a wars of aggression that Germany and Japan had started. The civilian populations of each country, whatever their war guilt, had experienced shattering levels of violence and privation in the final years of the war. And both countries were immediately faced by nearby hostile powers they feared much more than the United States. There are almost countless differences between the two historical situations, either separate from these points or growing out them. But taken together, these three factors explain a great deal of why our occupation of Iraq lacks both the legitimacy and the acceptance we enjoyed in those two countries.

The HIV Travel Ban

A reader writes:

I am a white South African, teaches Constitutional Law at an SA university and follow US politics very closely. I am supposed to go and teach at a Law School in the US for a few weeks next year but I am having such a hard time deciding whether I should or could do it. It would require me to ask for SPECIAL BLOODY PERMISSION to enter the US merely because of my HIV status and that seems so insulting and so reactionary to me. It suggests that being HIV positive is some kind of evil perverted disease that one should apologise for.

Even South Africa – whose President in the past have denied the link between HIV and AIDS – do not have a similar policy. It really makes me want to go to a more civilized place – Colombia? Sudan? Uzbekistan? – but I studied in New York and love the US so I do not know what to do. It is so sad that the US, who used to be a beacon of hope and light for many reasonable people in the world, has come to this.

It may be over soon. Here’s how you can help. It says something that George W. Bush has had a more retrograde policy on HIV in this solitary respect than Thabo Mbeki.

Overcoming Vitter, Ctd.

The former client of the DC Madam is the only real obstacle to removing the unique legislative prohibition against non-Americans with HIV visiting this country or immigrating here. Earlier, I asked readers to contact their own senators to urge them to support the PEPFAR renewal, with the bipartisan Smith-Kerry language removing this stigmatizing ban.

Please help. Here’s the link for all the senators’ email addresses and comment forms. If you have a minute, we can do this.

The Inside Track

More gun news:

Sound from the starter’s gun is known to take longer to reach athletes who start from the outside lanes than their competitors on the inside. Now a new study suggests that competitors nearest the gun have another advantage – the loudness of the bang shocks them into starting more quickly. Together, these extra boosts may amount to more than a tenth of a second in some races, which is easily enough to make the difference between gold and silver.

(Hat tip: Kottke.)