She asked Robert Johnson to push the idea.
Category: The Dish
A Real Re-Think
Reihan on what an Obama presidency may do to the right:
I think that many people will be disillusioned by President Obama, particularly if we really are at the beginning of a lasting food-fuel-credit crunch. The left is positively gleeful about the dire straits of the Republican party. My own sense is that the right is very fortunate: we have an opportunity, finally, for a real re-think. The left, in contrast, is creative mainly at the margins. They’ve won the political argument. They haven’t won the substantive argument.
The View From Your Window
Her Words
The McCain campaign is already using Clinton’s "Commander In Chief threshold" line against Obama. The RNC is also touting those lines:
Welcome to the general election. But remember: she lost using these tactics.
Honor
It still permeates vast swathes of the US military, is exemplified in the quiet but profound heroism of Medal Of Honor award winner, Sergeant First Class Paul Ray Smith, and yet we often do not appreciate what it means and what it costs. Bob Kaplan is one of those who has noticed:
The ceremony in the East Room of the White House two years to the day after Sergeant Smith was killed, where President George W. Bush awarded the Medal of Honor to Sergeant Smith’s 11-year-old son, David, was fitfully covered by the media. The Paul Ray Smith story elicited 96 media mentions for the eight week period after the medal was awarded, compared with 4,677 for the supposed abuse of the Koran at Guantánamo Bay and 5,159 for the disgraced Abu Ghraib prison guard Lynndie England, over a much longer time frame that went on for many months. In a society that obsesses over reality-TV shows, gangster and war movies, and NFL quarterbacks, an authentic hero like Sergeant Smith flickers momentarily before the public consciousness.
Smith’s moment of real heroism:
Sergeant Smith was directing his platoon to lay concertina wire across the corner of a courtyard near the airport, in order to create a temporary holding area for Iraqi prisoners of war. Then he noticed Iraqi troops massing, armed with AK-47s, RPGs, and mortars. Soon, mortar fire had wounded three of his men—the crew of the platoon’s M113A3 armored personnel carrier. A hundred well-armed Iraqis were now firing on his 16-man platoon.
Sergeant Smith threw grenades and fired an AT-4, a bazooka-like anti-tank weapon. A Bradley fighting vehicle from another unit managed to hold off the Iraqis for a few minutes, but then inexplicably left (out of ammunition, it would later turn out). Sergeant Smith was now in his rights to withdraw his men from the courtyard. But he rejected that option because it would have threatened American soldiers who were manning a nearby road block and an aid station. Instead, he decided to climb atop the Vietnam-era armored personnel carrier whose crew had been wounded and man the .50- caliber machine gun himself. He asked Private Michael Seaman to go inside the vehicle, and to feed him a box of ammunition whenever the private heard the gun go silent.
Seaman, under Sergeant Smith’s direction, moved the armored personnel carrier back a few feet to widen Smith’s field of fire. Sergeant Smith was now completely exposed from the waist up, facing 100 Iraqis firing at him from three directions, including from inside a well-protected sentry post. He methodically raked them, from right to left and back. Three times his gun went silent and three times the private reloaded him, while Sergeant Smith sat exposed to withering fire. He succeeded in breaking the Iraqi attack, killing perhaps dozens of the enemy while going through 400 rounds of ammunition, before being shot in the head.
Endgame Kabuki
Marc on the unity ticket:
…if Obama can coalesce the Democratic Party before he needs to pick a vice president, there’s almost no chance that he will pick Hillary Clinton.
“That is an astounding turn around for Andrew.”
It’s always nice to be flattered, but this post is a little uninformed. As readers know, I’ve long since come to the conclusion that the Iraq war was a terrible strategic mistake, conceptually and operationally. But I’ve just as long since been open to good things happening in a country that we do not well understand and that is in great flux. And I’ve been diligent in posting and linking to as much data and reporting in Iraq as possible, data that adds to the argument on all sides. I didn’t believe the surge would work because I didn’t believe that there were sufficient troops to make it a success (and believed at that point that giving the benefit of the doubt to the Bush administration was a form of insanity). But several factors – Petraeus’ obvious genius, the Sunni switch, Sadr’s temporary quietude, Maliki’s sudden urgency, and the knowledge that America’s patience was running low – seem to have tipped the balance. I am delighted to be proven tactically wrong – as I said at the time. But I have been adjusting to the facts on the ground for many months. There is nothing astounding about this post to diligent Dish readers.
More to the point: I do not regard this unexpected progress as a reason to insist on 50 permanent military bases in Iraq or for any other purpose than to find a way out of the place as expeditiously as possible. I see this progress as an opportunity to leave with as little collateral damage as possible.
And in fact, it seems clear to me that the American public’s growing impatience with the war was a factor in concentrating some Iraqi minds.
To those who say I was for the war before I was against it, I have long ago conceded the point. I don’t think one should hold onto an ideological position when the facts refute it, however painful such a concession would be. Strategically, when you factor in costs, blowback, the absence of WMDs, the blow to US credibility, the hundreds of thousands of dead and injured and displaced, the rise and fall of al Qaeda in Iraq, and the strengthening of Iran’s hold on the region, it is clear to me, as it is to most Americans, that the Iraq war was a terrible strategic blunder. But tactically, we are where we are, and no one should be anything but thrilled that the short term is brighter than we could have imagined only a few months ago.
A tactical shift has led to a tactical opportunity. We should leave as soon and as completely as responsibly possible.
Obama’s Obvious Next Move
My bet: The presumptive nominee will publicly offer Senator Clinton the lead role in his administration for healthcare reform. He may have to doll up the title to make it appear grander than HHS but some kind of cabinet level health czar position might work. Her fallback position is to offer to spearhead the legislation in the Senate – why not name the bill after her? – and campaign on this subject for the ticket through the fall. Offering her healthcare may be too petty for her privately; but that’s why it calls her bluff on the whole "I’m-just-doing-it-for-the-little-people" schtick. How can she be seen to treat healthcare reform as an insult to her stature? If it’s her cause celebre, how can it be beneath her?
Fantasy Team Of Rivals time: Clinton gets healthcare; Edwards gets poverty; Gore gets the environment; the other Clinton is made secretary of state.
He can offer, can’t he?
Quote For The Day
"For all the negative stuff that is being put out there about his church, it is the womb that turned out a man with an audacity to hope. If he’s so nationalistic and crass and all these things and he’s so racist and all of these things people like to attribute [to him]—how come he taught a man that is so inclusive, has such a tent, has such a vision for the future for change and for hope that is attracting so many? I’d think every pastor in the nation would like to turn out a Barack Obama. If Jeremiah is so bad, well damn, let me be that bad," – Father Michael Pfleger, talking to Dayo Opolade, much earlier this year.
Obama At AIPAC
I hear reports of a tour de force. Money quote:
"The danger from Iran is grave and real and my goal will be to eliminate this threat," he said, adding loudly to add emphasis that he would do "everything" to prevent Iran from obtaining a nuclear weapon… "As president of the United States, I would be willing to lead tough and principled diplomacy with the appropriate Iranian leader at a time and place of my choosing — if, and only if — it can advance the interests of the United States."

