Ezra Klein surmises:
She understands, she just doesn’t accept.
Ezra Klein surmises:
She understands, she just doesn’t accept.
This is getting absurd. From this morning’s conference call for the New York Congressional delegation:
Rep. Nita Lowey made a plea for patience. The reality, she said, is that the party has to unify, but Hillary needs some time to adjust… maybe even two weeks.
A reader writes:
The mischievous contrarian in me is enjoying the debacle of Doug Kmiec being denied communion. Perhaps it will teach him, and others, what it is like to be on the wrong side of authoritarianism, excessive moralizing, and the politicization of faith. It seems to me inevitable that if you employ what amounts to a religious test for your politics, that the same logic would justify a political test for your religion. If the two are so tightly fused that they become indistinguishable — if the liberal compromise of acknowledging politics as a sphere to itself, with, in a sense, its own reasons and discourse, is essentially rejected — then how could it be otherwise?
You see this rejection of liberalism, in the best and truest sense of the word, when people like Ross Douthat use language like this:
"…a legislator who happens to support deeply-immoral measures…" I for one think there is a meaningful distinction between being pro-choice and supporting abortion, between allowing others to make choices we find morally problematic and actually urging or even demanding others make those choices. I sincerely believe that there are few things more moral, decent, humane, and dare I say Christian than refraining from using the coercive power of the state to punish those who do not agree with every tenet of your moral system. This is not "relativism" — this is an ethic of restraint when it comes to politics.
If anything, this episode affirms for me that the best reason to separate politics and religion is not because religion poisons our politics, but because religion is too beautiful, profound, and important to be sullied by the frauds and factions that run our political system. It grieves my heart to see my faith bandied about in this way. All I want is to be left alone to worship, to eat and drink Christ, to pray, and to love my neighbor. The Kmiec situation reminds us that, when you go after others, sometimes they go after you. Power is strange like that, isn’t it? It always — always! — cuts both ways.
Dana Milbank charts the Clinton camp’s slide into the ridiculous.
Obama:
Clinton:
McCain:
Michelle Cottle bids Clinton goodbye:
Right up until the end, a part of me really wanted her to pull it off. Oh sure, I grant the Obamaniacs everything: Hillary’s divisiveness, her baggage, her "likeability issue"-all fueled by her special blend of moral flexibility and arch moralism. On a good day, Hillary Clinton rubs approximately half the country the wrong way. And as her fading primary prospects made the good days ever rarer, the candidate, her team, and most particularly that unhinged husband of hers pulled a variety of stunts that reminded all of us exactly how fatiguing the Clintons can be.
Still it breaks my heart to see her laid low.
Not mine.
"A black man will be his party’s nominee to be president of the United States. If you were a betting man and you had to place a bet on who is going to win in November, you would be prudent to place it on him. He is a problematic candidate, but not because of his father’s ancestry; rather, because of his views. He will carry aloft the standard of a great political party and a powerful ideological coalition. This is a culminating moment for the United States," – John Podhoretz.
John Dickerson writes:
In the pageant of reconciliation, Clinton, who has promised to campaign vigorously for Obama, will be repeatedly asked about her claims that he lacked the credentials to be commander in chief and would not be able to defeat John McCain. That will be hard enough for her. But it’s not all. Unlike other second-place finishers who have merely had to sublimate their own ambition, Clinton will have to engage in the eclipsing of her husband’s presidency and its legacy, which has largely defined the Democratic Party for the last 15 years.
Barack Obama didn’t just run against Hillary Clinton. He ran against Clintonism.
The assault started indirectly in his book, The Audacity of Hope, which spoke about moving past the generational fights that had consumed baby boomers in the 1990s. He was attacking both parties for their preoccupation with Vietnam and the warmed-over cultural battles of the ’60s and ’70s, but on the Democratic side, this was an explicit effort to push away from the biggest boomer of all, Bill Clinton, and the turmoil of his reign.
Ross continues to defend his article’s thesis:
…if Bush does succeed – as seems increasingly plausible – in finally delivering a fragile-but-improving situation in Iraq to his successor, that won’t be an achievement that ought to vindicate his initial decision to invade. But provisionally, at least, the way that Bush has unwound himself on Iraq has been more impressive, and provided more grist for a potential rehabilitation, than a simple volte-face would have.
If Bush had taken the Baker-Hamilton Commission’s advice, for instance, and the security situation had gradually improved thereafter, the obvious historical narrative would have been that Bush led America into a disaster, and then had to turn things over to the grown-ups and let them lead us out. But by instead choosing a course-correction – the Surge – that had very little institutional support within American political circles, Bush assumed ownership of subsequent events in a way that most politicians seeking to undo their blunders don’t have the opportunity to do. And should Iraq reach some sort of democratic stability over the long run, it’s very easy to see how Bush’s decision to double down rather than pulling out could become one of the high points of a larger narrative that paints him as a visionary.
Clinton’s speech – my real-time reaction here – pushed normally temperate Fallows to type in caps:
You HAVE LOST the nomination. There are NO MORE primaries. And you’re urging your supporters to nurse their bitter feelings on your web site, and keep selling their bikes to give you money that you’ll spend on… what? The unseemliness — and, yes, destructiveness — of this is too obvious to mention, though perhaps not obvious enough to have occurred to you. This is a new low.
So she’s going to leave it to her voters to decide whether she should accept defeat after having, you know, lost? What if every losing candidate left it to their supporters to decide whether or not to accept the outcome of a race? Who would ever accept defeat?
What good could possibly come of this?
With Hillary proclaiming herself the legitimate winner, they’re clearly going to say "keep going." If she actually does keep going, that’s a disaster for the Democratic Party. And if she doesn’t, you’ve just drawn a ton of attention to the fact that a large chunk of the party doesn’t accept Obama as the legimiate nominee. No, worse: you’ve encouraged them to think that, then drawn attention to it.
I don’t know what the fallout will be, but at minimum, I’d say that anybody on her staff who cares about their party has a moral obligation to publicly quit and endorse Obama.
If Clinton wants people to believe that she cares more about the Democratic Party than her own career, she is failing badly.
Hillary Clinton had one last chance, tonight, to exit the stage with dignity. She missed it.
JPod:
You don’t get psychodrama like this very often. It’s like political reality TV.