Rick On Chris

Hertzberg praises Matthews:

The profile that ran in the New York Times Magazine a few weeks ago captured some of Chris (the insecurity, the self-promotion), but some is not all. The insecurity without the huge appetite for life, the self-promotion without the empathic social conscience that lurks somewhere behind all that love of the political game—these give a distorted impression. Chris Matthews is a net plus for American politics and American society.

I’m a regular on his show so you can dismiss this if you like, but I agree with Rick. Chris Matthews is a sometimes clumsy, but always decent person. His heart is very large and invariably in the right place. My one disagreement with Rick: hating the Clintons is not reducible to some strange atheist idea of what a Catholic’s idea of forgiveness is. The reason so many people who were brought up in a traditional Catholic household loathe the Clintons – Dowd, Kelly, Russert, Matthews, Sullivan, et al. – is because we were taught the difference between right and wrong, and taught to believe it matters.

That’s all.

The Rules Committee

Marc offers a preview of the meeting on the 31st:

Almost certainly, Hillary Clinton will be disappointed at the results. But there won’t be much sympathy for her. She will have succeeded in changing the total number of delegates needed to reach the nomination, and she will have been awarded MORE NET delegtes then she received organically from her victory in a state like Ohio. She may threaten to protest the RBC’s decision to the rules and bylaws committee, but I doubt that her supporters will stomach a credentials fight.

And The Page reports DNC lawyers wrote a memo saying that Michigan and Florida can’t be fully seated.

Jihadism Defeating Itself? Ctd.

An interesting piece on the collapse of al Qaeda in Iraq. No one should take away from Petraeus’ tactical genius, but the nutjobs of the Jihadist fringe certainly knew how to injure themselves. They key was over-reach. They killed too many sympathetic civilians, and their surreal announcement of a new Caliphate forced even supporters to roll their eyes:

This defeat was not as sudden as it appeared to be, and some Islamic terrorist web sites have been discussing the problem for several years. The primary cause has been  Moslems killed as a side effect of attacks on infidel troops, Iraqi security forces and non-Sunnis. Al Qaeda plays down the impact of this, calling the Moslem victims "involuntary martyrs." But that’s a minority opinion. Most Moslems, and many other Islamic terrorists, see this as a surefire way to turn the Moslem population against the Islamic radicals. That’s what happened earlier in Algeria, Afghanistan, Egypt and many other places. It’s really got nothing to do with religion. The phenomenon hits non-Islamic terrorists as well (like the Irish IRA and the Basque ETA).

Maybe this will be history’s judgment of the last few years: both the US and al Qaeda over-reached. But al Qaeda’s over-reach was greater. And in this we see why democracies do actually do better in warfare in the long run: because our leaders have to be responsive to the people; because legitimate internal criticism and debate forces course correction and exposes self-defeating hubris. With the Bush administration, this process took much longer than it should have, and the Bushies did all they could to stamp out, rather than hear, criticism. But in the end, democracy adjusts to reality; religious extremism cannot.

Jihadism Defeating Itself?

Baghdadahmadalrubayeafpgetty

That is the hope expressed in Lawrence Wright’s latest stunner of a reported essay in the New Yorker. Money quote:

“We now have before us two schools of thought,” Kamal Habib, [a key leader of the first generation of Al Jihad], told me. “The old school, which was expressed by Al Jihad and its spinoff, Al Qaeda, is the one that was led by Ayman al-Zawahiri, Sheikh Maqdisi, Zarqawi. The new school, which Dr. Fadl has given expression to, represents a battle of faith. It’s deeper than just ideology.” He went on, “The general mood of Islamist movements in the seventies was intransigence. Now the general mood is toward harmony and coexistence. The distance between the two is a measure of their experience.” Ironically, Dr. Fadl’s thinking gave birth to both schools. “As long as a person lives in a world of jihad, the old vision will control his thinking,” Habib suggested. “When he’s in battle, he doesn’t wonder if he’s wrong or he’s right. When he’s arrested, he has time to wonder.”

It’s also Fareed’s tentative observation:

The Simon Fraser study notes that the decline in terrorism appears to be caused by many factors, among them successful counterterrorism operations in dozens of countries and infighting among terror groups. But the most significant, in the study’s view, is the "extraordinary drop in support for Islamist terror organizations in the Muslim world over the past five years." These are largely self-inflicted wounds. The more people are exposed to the jihadists’ tactics and world view, the less they support them.

An ABC/BBC poll in Afghanistan in 2007 showed support for the jihadist militants in the country to be 1 percent. In Pakistan’s North-West Frontier province, where Al Qaeda has bases, support for Osama bin Laden plummeted from 70 percent in August 2007 to 4 percent in January 2008. That dramatic drop was probably a reaction to the assassination of Benazir Bhutto, but it points to a general trend in Pakistan over the past five years. With every new terrorist attack, public support for jihad falls. "This pattern is repeated in country after country in the Muslim world," writes Mack. "Its strategic implications are critically important because historical evidence suggests that terrorist campaigns that lose public support will sooner or later be abandoned or defeated."

Know hope.

(Photo: A child wounded by a terror attack in Baghdad, by Ahmad al Rubaye/AFP/Getty.)

Where Hillary Resides

A reader writes:

If Hillary was to concede from a Circle of Hell, it would definitely be the 8th circle, Bolgia 9, where dwellest the "Sowers of Discord", including political discord.

The ninth circle, reserved for Traitors, would be a nice place for her to announce that she’s staying in until the convention.