"You have to ask yourself, who is the stronger candidate? And based on every analysis, of every bit of research and every poll that has been taken and every state that a Democrat has to win, I am the stronger candidate against John McCain in the fall," – Senator Hillary Clinton, yesterday. Fact check here.
Category: The Dish
The Reality Of War
If you wonder why some soldiers suffer post-traumatic stress, this first-hand testimony from a soldier who served in Iraq, and found himself unrecognizable after a while, may help. It seems to me that Petraeus’ efforts have been admirable and the results beyond anything I imagined – or most predicted (including many Petraeus fans). At the same time, we need to look war in the face. It is an ugly, ugly thing.
Race Or Racism?
McWhorter and Loury talk about the impact of skin color and culture in the fall election.
Brewster Rockit, Space Guy
A blog-war has broken out:
Don’t Tease
Ben Smith considers where Clinton will pull out of the race. Which circle of hell would that be?
Al Qaeda’s WMD “Threat”
A prank?
By The Numbers
Hertzberg on the popular vote:
With or without participants in the caucus states of Iowa, Nevada, Maine, and Washington (i.e., states where voters’ preferences were expressed by gathering in corners and the like, and whose numbers can be estimated but are not pinpointed), and with the totals for both Florida (whose primary was unsanctioned by the Democratic Party, with the consent of all the candidates, and where no one campaigned) and Michigan (also unsanctioned, and where Obama’s name was not even on the ballot), Clinton’s claim that more people have “voted” for her is factual. But her claim to be “ahead” depends entirely on a tally for the Michigan primary that is distinctly North Korean: Clinton, 328,309; Obama, 0. However, if the bulk of the 238,168 Michiganders who voted “uncommitted” are assumed to have been Obama supporters—a reasonable assumption—then Obama leads by every possible reckoning. And if only Florida is included, then Obama leads whether or not those four caucuses are counted.
Yglesias Award Nominee
"In the end, Hillary will do what’s best for her, and taking a credentials fight to the convention floor, especially if it’s a losing one, is not going to be best for her. And Obama will do what’s best for him, and if it’s not picking Hillary to run with him, there’s nothing she or anyone else can do to force him to change his mind. That’s just the way it is, and should be," – Susan Estrich.
McClellan’s Grave Charge
It would be easy to think of Scott McClellan’s new book as a piece of dish, designed for sales, pitched for controversy, packed with juicy detail. And it is that, of course. But it is also something more. It is an argument by a man very, very close to the president, and deputed to be his spokesman for many years, that the president deliberately deceived the country about the reasons for going to war. We’re not talking mistakes here; we’re talking about a deliberate shading of the truth to hide the real motivation for risking the lives of thousands of soldiers and hundreds of thousands of innocent civilians:
In Iraq, McClellan added, Bush saw "his opportunity to create a legacy of greatness," something McClellan said Bush has said he believes is only available to wartime presidents.
The president’s real motivation for the war, he said, was to transform the Middle East to ensure an enduring peace in the region. But the White House effort to sell the war as necessary due to the stated threat posed by Saddam Hussein was needed because "Bush and his advisers knew that the American people would almost certainly not support a war launched primarily for the ambitions purpose of transforming the Middle East," McClellan wrote.
"Rather than open this Pandora’s Box, the administration chose a different path — not employing out-and-out deception, but shading the truth," he wrote of the effort to convince the world that Saddam had weapons of mass destruction, an effort he said used "innuendo and implication" and "intentional ignoring of intelligence to the contrary."
"President Bush managed the crisis in a way that almost guaranteed that the use of force would become the only feasible option," McClellan concluded, noting, "The lack of candor underlying the campaign for war would severely undermine the president’s entire second term in office."
If this is true, if the president intentionally ignored data refuting the existence of Saddam’s WMDs, he should be impeached.
The Wrong Guy
A citizen’s arrest of John Bolton for war crimes? Wrong guy. Cheney, Rumsfeld, Bush, Powell, Rice, Gonzales, Addington, Yoo, Haynes: these are the torture-enforcers.
