Ask Josh Fox Anything: Is Fracking A Necessary Evil?

The writer/director of Gasland and Gasland II replies:

Meanwhile, Claire Thompson passes along some news from California:

On Monday, the state Assembly’s Natural Resources Committee approved no fewer than three bills calling for a moratorium on hydraulic fracturing until its environmental and health effects are thoroughly studied by the state. Meanwhile, another bill pending in the state Senate would allow fracking to continue for now but would impose a moratorium if the state fails to complete a comprehensive review by January 2015. …

It’s not just [environmentalists] who want to keep their state frack-free. California’s powerful agricultural interests are also calling for more regulation and oversight, given the threat this water-intensive and water-polluting process poses to crops. And considering the growing evidence that fracking can cause earthquakes, every citizen of this already seismically unstable state has reason to be concerned. The state’s fracking fight is centered around the Monterey Shale in Southern California, which holds two-thirds of the country’s estimated oil reserves. Production there had been dwindling until the recent rise of fracking and horizontal drilling made hard-to-reach reserves accessible, and now oil companies are chomping at the bit.

Gasland II just premiered at Tribeca and will air on HBO this summer. Ask Anything archive here.

Marriage Equality Goes Local

Balko reports from Bisbee, Arizona, whose officials recently generated a firestorm by passing an ordinance permitting civil unions:

“Both Councilman Conners and I live in the ward with the highest LGBT population,” says Bisbee Mayor Adriana Badal. “And proportionally, Bisbee itself has one of the highest gay and lesbian populations in the state. We decided we wanted to do something real. Not a resolution, but something that carries the force of law.”

The problem is that in the U.S., most legal protections for marriage are codified at the state level. Conners and Badal knew they couldn’t grant rights to same-sex couples that the state wouldn’t enforce, but they did come up with an ordinance that granted as many legal protections as a small town could.

Bisbee, for example, owns a cemetery, so the ordinance granted the same interment rights to same-sex couples and their families that the town gives to heterosexual families. The ordinance also granted same-sex families the right to get family passes at the public swimming pool, the right to the same land-use permits, and — perhaps most significantly — visitation rights and power of attorney to make medical decisions at the local hospital. …

Within 12 hours of the ordinance passing, Arizona Attorney General Tom Horne raised concerns that Bisbee had usurped some of the state’s powers, and possibly violated a constitutional amendment passed in 2008 that defined marriage as “only a union of one man and one woman.” Horne threatened to sue to have the new policy overturned.

Tom Prezelski wonders why the issue has become such a concern to state legislators:

It would be welcome if folks at the Capitol were to look at Bisbee to see what they could do to make sure that such towns have the resources to address issues of economic development and to keep their streets paved. Even though these things are well within the purview of the Legislature, they are hardly a priority for our state’s leadership. Instead, we get this needless meddling in local affairs. … The chest-thumping from Arizona’s political leadership about freedom rings a bit hollow when it becomes clear that they have little respect for the freedom of folks in communities that look different than their own.

State and local officials were able to resolve the issue, however:

Lawyers working with the city council from the pro-gay marriage group Lambda Legal said the city will omit the “spouse” reference in favor of “family partnership” or “registered partnership.” Other references to rights prohibited under the state constitution will be dropped. Instead, the city will work with gays and lesbians to help them enter into civil contracts such as wills and healthcare proxies — already available to any citizen — when they apply for civil union status.

The compromise provides a template for other municipalities in the state seeking to offer some form of legal recognition for same-sex couples. Officials in Tempe, Ariz., said they are considering adopting a similar law in that city.

Did The Saudis Warn the US About Tsarnaev?

That’s what one unnamed Saudi official has told Britain’s Daily Mail. That does change the equation in terms of “stove-piping” since 9/11. But I would just note that this is in the Mail – not exactly a barometer of reliability – and that the piece contains its own caveat:

If true, the account will produce added pressure on the Homeland Security department and the White House to explain their collective inaction after similar warnings were offered about Tsarnaev by the Russian government. A DHS official denied, however, that the agency received any such warning from Saudi intelligence about Tamerlan Tsarnaev.

My italics. For more context on the Mail, see this hilarious video. Meantime, we’ll wait for confirmation.

Is Osama Alive Or Still Dead?

Mutually conflicting conspiracy theories often coexist:

[W]hile it has been known for some time that people who believe in one conspiracy theory are also likely to believe in other conspiracy theories, we would expect contradictory conspiracy theories to be negatively correlated.

Yet, this is not what psychologists Micheal Wood, Karen Douglas and Robbie Suton found in a recent study. Instead, the research team, based at the University of Kent in England, found that many participants believed in contradictory conspiracy theories. For example, the conspiracy-belief that Osama Bin Laden is still alive was positively correlated with the conspiracy-belief that he was already dead before the military raid took place. This makes little sense, logically: Bin Laden cannot be both dead and alive at the same time. An important conclusion that the authors draw from their analysis is that people don’t tend to believe in a conspiracy theory because of the specifics, but rather because of higher-order beliefs that support conspiracy-like thinking more generally. A popular example of such higher-order beliefs is a severe “distrust of authority.”

Undertreating Mental Illness

In the shadow of her own family history of schizophrenia, Mac McClelland investigates the neglect of mental health treatment across the US, “where the three largest de facto psychiatric facilities are jails.” In San Francisco’s impoverished Tenderloin neighborhood:

The majority of [community center director Cindy] Gyori’s clients are suffering afflictions like PTSD, anxiety, depression, and the associated addiction issues. That is: With treatment, they’re theoretically capable of recovery and (nonsubsidized) functioning. But Gyori’s staff is short, underpaid. New clients can’t be seen for initial risk assessment for a month. The city’s public-housing shortage is so severe that it closed the list to new applicants. “This society is set up to create Tenderloins,” she says.

“We’re dealing with the most stigmatized and misunderstood population. You can scream outside my window,” she says, turning her face in the direction of the guy screaming outside her window—something about “dinner”—”and I’m not gonna make assumptions that it’s your fault. As long as a person is disabled, and income is limited, you have to help them. Destigmatization is a big part of it.”

Sure.

When I leave the clinic, it is admittedly difficult not to judge the strung-out-looking fellow lunging through the crosswalk hollering a song about monkeys, the refrain of which is a monkey call, or the parties responsible for the two piles of human shit I sidestep in as many blocks. Though an estimated 1 in 5 families contains someone with a mental illness, even families of the mentally ill aren’t always sympathetic. “We have families who aren’t willing to work with us or do anything,” says my Aunt Terri’s caseworker, Eleanor. “Your family was so willing; everybody was there to do whatever.” But she’s certainly not talking about my great-grandmother, who pronounced Terri lazy, and not even so much my grandfather, who thought his daughter was a spoiled brat who just wanted attention. And she wasn’t talking about me, whose total uselessness in Terri’s transportation and other needs earned me the resentment of at least one cousin.

Needing A Nook To Be Free

Hugo Macdonald counters the view that small spaces are claustrophobic:

Time once was when rooms in houses were divided into small spaces – each with a prescribed function. It sounds ridiculous. You cooked in the kitchen, ate dinner in the dining room, lived in the living room and so on. The rise of open-plan living after the war was “modern” and progressive, thanks to the dictum of Le Corbusier. It was healthy to let air circulate. And partition walls went the way of the dodo – the enemy of the architect, the preserve of the uncultured. Open-plan living was aspirational. In the 1980s you were nobody if you couldn’t cook, entertain, run a bath and lie in bed all in the same room. A cavernous converted warehouse apartment with exposed brick was the stuff of dreams – endless, uninterrupted space to live and party in. …

We’re constantly reminded that more of us are living alone in singledom than ever before. Could it be that the lofty open-plan living we’re so accustomed to, where couples live in the same single space, is in fact stifling us to distraction and divorce? “Needing space” in a relationship is a little misleading – it should be reworded to “needing spaces”.

Low Prices, High Art

Maria Godoy admires the work of Brendan O’Connell, painter of Walmart tableaux:

Wal-Mart stores, he notes, are “probably one of the most trafficked interior spaces in the world.” In the tall, open, cathedral-like ceilings of Wal-Mart’s big-box stores, he sees parallels to church interiors of old. “There is something in us that aspires to some kind of transcendence,” he told me back in February. “And as we’ve culturally turned from religious things, we’ve turned our transcendence to acquisition and satisfying desires.”

He says it’s not his most expensive paintings that are selling:

Media reports have lingered over the fact that some of his largest paintings — those 8 feet by 9 feet or so — can fetch $40,000 or more. But O’Connell says it’s the small works in the $1,000-$1,200 range that have been selling. And the people doing the buying, he says, come from all over the country. “What I’m struck by is this relationship to brands,” he says, noting that buyers have called to inquire about specific paintings: ” ‘Do you still have the Corn Flakes? … I want the Maxwell House.’ Whatever brand it is that they have a personal relationship with. And that, to me, is fascinating.”

Susan Orleans’ recent profile of O’Connoll touched on the company’s reaction:

[O’Connell] had never had any official communication with Walmart beyond the local managers inviting him to leave. A dealer who was interested in his work had once approached the company about acquiring one of the paintings but was told that Walmart didn’t buy art. Then, by chance, the Globe article was forwarded to Suraya Bliss, a senior director of digital strategy at the company. Bliss says that she has always been interested in visual things, and collects art herself, and she liked what O’Connell was doing. Instead of interpreting the paintings as arch commentary, she thought he was speaking to the company’s mission. “I got in touch with him and said, ‘Let’s talk and get to know each other,'” Bliss told me. After their conversation, she was convinced that his work was ‘very pure and very genuine.’ She arranged for him to take pictures in stores whenever he wanted, and offered to let him photograph from a cherry picker in one of the New Jersey superstores.

O’Connell is also working on a project, Everyartist.me, which hopes to engage millions of  kids in art.

This Is Your Town On Drugs, Ctd

A reader writes:

I volunteer with the juvenile court in my county. As a result, I work with many parents who are unfortunate enough to have an opiate addiction. I also have a relative with an opiate addiction. My county is not quite as poor as Oxyana, but the demographics are much the same. As a result, we have a lot of opiate addiction here (SW Ohio) and I would say it is the number one drug problem by a large margin. Of the three articles you reference, Warren Jason Street comes the closest to depicting the reality of this problem. But, in my mind, the key quote in his article is not the one you excerpted. It is, rather:

First of all, there is a massive difference between recreational drugs and prescription drugs. In the case of Oceana, West Virginia, the difference couldn’t be more stark–doctors and pharmacies and pharmaceutical companies have profited handsomely at the expense of the citizens who were handed Oxycontin prescriptions to help them deal with “pain.” This is a case of for-profit exploitation, and a tragic one at that.

I attend continuing education conferences every year as part of my volunteer  work. Last year I participated in a seminar given by a drug treatment counselor in southern Ohio. After listening to him talk about opiate addiction and what contributes to it, it’s very clear to me that certain communities are most definitely targeted by “pain” clinic operators.

They set up the pill mills to reach a certain audience, predominately poor/working-class white folks. They staff them with doctors who are ethically challenged (at best!), hang out a shingle, and then proceed to carpet the area with prescription opiates. The drug stores turn their heads and fill the prescriptions.

It’s a massive problem in Florida as well. As a matter of fact, a trip down I-75 will expose you to large billboards advertising pain clinics. My point? These folks addicted to pain killers aren’t just weak-willed hedonists who can’t stop; they have been deliberately and evilly targeted – and only Warren Jason Street seems to understand this.

It’s not clear that any of the authors you cite realize that the manufacturers of Oxycontin were fined by the FDA for deceptive marketing practices. They claimed that Oxy wasn’t addictive and marketed it to doctors that way. It’s clear that Frum doesn’t understand diddly squat about this problem. But perhaps he only objects to street drug dealers, not corporate drug dealers?

There’s much much more evil to the opiate addiction problem. I would love to see some investigative journalism that was able to tie together the collusion of the large drug companies, the large drug store chains like CVS, and the pain clinic operators. I realize that I sound like a foaming at the mouth conspiracy theorist, but I think there’s a lot more to this story than even the documentary shows.